Which Windows laptop display is best for Lightroom photo editing?

Asked 1/23/2012

8 views

2 answers

0

I’m replacing an older Dell XPS and want a portable Windows laptop mainly for editing RAW files in Lightroom. My priority is the display quality rather than gaming or general use.

Requirements:

  • Windows laptop only
  • Around 15.6 inches
  • Best possible built-in screen for photo editing
  • Portability matters, so an external monitor isn’t an option

What display technologies or laptop lines should I look for if I want the most accurate and usable screen for photographic post-processing?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

5

For the last 2 years I've been using a Dell Studio XPS 16 (with Windows 7) and in terms of image quality it's far and away the best computer screen I've ever used. Although this model is no longer available to buy new, I'm sure there are comparable models. I wouldn't hesitate to buy the same again, although it does have some drawbacks.

Specific pros and cons are as follows.

Pros

  1. The screen is LED-backlit, as opposed to the older fluorescent lamp backlit style of LCD. This makes for a brighter, more even backlight that doesn't degrade as the display ages. My last laptop's screen (fluorescent backlit) was very dim after a couple of years.
  2. Moreover, the backlight uses RGB LEDs: clusters of red, green and blue LEDs rather than white ones. This produces a wide gamut display with excellent contrast and colour reproduction.

Cons

  1. The wide gamut display has to be properly calibrated, and using a calibration device with explicit wide gamut support. Out of the box it's pretty much useless for photo work because everything's way over-saturated, but once calibrated it's perfect. It just means you need to factor the cost of a Sypder 3 Pro or similar into your purchase. (See my answer to this question for plenty more information on this.)
  2. It's a 16:9 ratio HD screen (1920x1080). I'd prefer something squarer for photo work but I soon got used to it and regardless of ratio it's still a nice big screen.

No other device I've used (other laptops including a brand new MacBook Air, iPads, phones, etc.) come close to this screen in terms of colour reproduction. That's not a PC/Mac thing, it's an RGB LED thing. Once you've used an RGB LED screen for photography work there's no going back!

Originally by user3644. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user3644

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For photo editing on a Windows laptop, the key is the panel technology more than the brand name. Look for a 15–16 inch model with an IPS/PLS-class display (or branded versions like HP DreamColor and Dell PremierColor), since these typically offer better viewing angles, more consistent color, and often wider gamut than typical TN panels.

Some older Dell Studio XPS models were praised for their strong displays, especially LED-backlit wide-gamut panels. Another answer also praised a Maingear ALT-15 with the optional matte screen for color accuracy. But specific models change quickly, so the safest advice is to shop by screen specs.

What to check:

  • IPS/PLS panel, not TN
  • Full HD or better resolution
  • Good sRGB coverage at minimum
  • Matte screen if you want fewer reflections
  • Reviews that measure color accuracy and gamut

Also note: not every IPS laptop panel is truly excellent, and some can still miss parts of sRGB or have color quirks, so verify the exact panel in the exact configuration you’re buying.

In short: prioritize IPS-class panels and confirmed color-gamut/accuracy reviews over any single laptop brand.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer