Which upgrade matters more for birds in flight: a longer lens or a better camera body?

Asked 10/27/2010

8 views

2 answers

0

My wife shoots birds with a Canon 450D and a 70-300mm lens. I’m considering upgrading either the camera body to something like a Canon 7D or the lens to a longer telephoto such as a Canon EF 100-400mm or 400mm prime. If I can only buy one upgrade for bird photography—especially birds in flight—which would make the bigger difference?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

7

The 100-400 is an awesome lens for bird photography. it's my go-to lens, and I do about 90% of my nature work with it. Works well carrying it around and is pretty fast and flexible. I work with a crop sensor, primarily a 7d, and I recommend a crop sensor for bird photography for the magnification it brings. the 7D is a killer body for this use.

When I'm working off of a tripod, I tend to use a 300/F4 and a 1.4x Teleconverter. It's a little sharper and a small bit more powerful than the 100-400 @400mm.

You will find that 400mm is not powerful enough at times; I do wish a lot for 400mm or 500mm lens, especially one I can slap a 1.4x tele on. The cost difference going from 300m to 400mm is prohibitive for me right now, so I make do. You can do quite well with the 100-400.

(just back from a trip shooting at a refuge; this was primarily shot with the 300/1.4x combo on the 7d: http://www.chuqui.com/2010/10/dawn-patrol/; here's a shot taken with the 100-400 from earlier this year: http://www.flickr.com/photos/chuqui/4980414951/ )

So I highly recommend the 100-400 as a good lens for this. The 300/F4 and 1.4x is another option to consider and probably a bit less expensive. You can buy BOTH for less than a 400mm or 50mm would cost, so they're good lenses for getting going here without committing to a mortgage. But trust me, if you catch the bug for bird photography, at some point, you'll be budgeting for ever bigger and more powerful lenses...

Originally by user705. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user705

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For bird photography, especially birds in flight, the bigger gain usually comes from more reach. A 70-300mm can work, but many bird photographers consider 400mm about the minimum for consistently strong results, and even that can feel short at times. The goal is often a frame-filling shot, which usually means a longer lens plus getting as close as you can.

From the answers, the Canon 100-400mm is a strong all-around choice: good reach, flexible zoom range, and practical for carrying and handholding. A 400mm prime can also be excellent, and a 300mm f/4 with a 1.4x teleconverter was noted as a sharp tripod-based option.

A crop-sensor body like the Canon 7D is also well liked for birds because it pairs well with long lenses and gives a tighter field of view. But if you can buy only one item, the lens upgrade is likely to make the more noticeable difference first. If budget allows later, pairing a 400mm-class lens with a crop body is a very strong setup for birding.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer