Which image format should I use on a smartphone to preserve metadata and avoid compression for MTF testing?
Asked 5/25/2021
8 views
2 answers
0
I’m shooting with a smartphone and want files that keep as much camera metadata as possible while minimizing image processing and compression, because I’m trying to measure MTF and related metrics. JPEG files seem to contain more EXIF data than PNG, but JPEG is lossy. My phone can also save WebP, and sometimes RAW. Which capture format is the best choice for this kind of technical image analysis?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
2
One very good option is to use TIFF format as it support EXIF, IPTC. Also you can store the images in uncompressed, lossless compressed, lossy compressed form. You can have multipage files. As benefit TIFF support 8,16,24,32 even more (for some colour space/compression) bits. And it support RGB, CMYK, YCbCr colour spaces.
But be aware usually the size of TIFF is bigger than JPG.
Originally by user34947. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user34947
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
If your phone offers RAW, use RAW. It generally preserves the most original sensor data and includes the metadata the camera records, making it the best option for technical analysis like MTF.
JPEG also supports extensive EXIF metadata, but it is lossy and already includes in-camera processing such as tone, sharpening, noise reduction, and color conversion. That processing can affect measurements.
PNG is not a good choice here: it typically carries less camera metadata and isn’t a common camera-native capture format.
WebP also isn’t ideal for MTF work. Its advantages don’t help for this use, and it’s typically 8-bit output with image processing already applied.
TIFF can support rich metadata and even lossless or uncompressed storage, but camera-recorded TIFF is usually still a processed image rather than untouched sensor data, so it’s generally not better than RAW for measurement purposes.
If RAW is unavailable, use JPEG with the least aggressive processing settings your phone allows.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What lossy formats can compress 16-bit grayscale images without reducing dynamic range?
How much does Nikon’s lossy-compressed 14-bit NEF affect real-world image quality vs JPEG?
Why don’t cameras usually offer PNG as a capture format?
Best lossy archival format for 16-bit TIFF edits
How can I migrate Picasa face tags to digiKam without changing image file hashes?