Which flash modes generally use the least power?
Asked 3/1/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m trying to understand whether certain camera flash modes are more battery-efficient than others. Modes I’m thinking of include fill flash, slow sync / slow shutter flash, high-speed sync, and rear-curtain sync. Assuming no exposure compensation, do any of these modes inherently use less flash power, or does power use depend more on the scene and exposure settings?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
7
Let's discuss what each of the terms mentioned in your question means.
Fill Flash: When there is enough overall light in the scene to take a picture, but there are shadows that need to be smoothed out, fill flash can be used to lighten the shadows. Even outdoors on a sunny day, if the sun is high overhead or behind your subject you can use fill flash to even out the light. The camera computes the shutter speed and/or aperture needed for the overall scene, then adds enough flash to fill in the shadows. You may need to adjust Flash Exposure Compensation to get the look you want. The power needed can be very little to full power, depending on the shooting conditions.
Slow Sync Flash (a/k/a Slow Shutter Flash): This is the counterpart of fill flash. When there is not enough light to take a good exposure but you want many areas of the scene to be lit. The camera computes the shutter speed needed to properly expose the background, the flash fires with just enough power to properly illuminate your subject. Shutter speed will generally be slow enough that the camera will need to be supported in some way to prevent blur caused by camera movement. The amount of power needed will vary, depending on the scene.
High Speed Sync: Each camera with a mechanical shutter has a speed that is the fastest it is capable to sync with a flash. It is usually around 1/200 to 1/250 sec, but can be much faster or slower depending on the camera. At speeds faster than this the second curtain of the shutter begins to close before the first curtain is completely open. The sensor (or film) is not being exposed all at the same time, but instead is being exposed from top to bottom (or side to side for most older film cameras) by the opening between the two curtains. The faster the shutter speed, the narrower the gap between the first and second curtain. Since an electric flash strobes at a very short duration, only the fraction of the sensor that is behind the slit between the two curtains will be exposed to the light from the flash, and the top and bottom of the frame will have dark bars across them. The solution when flash is needed at a high shutter speed is for the flash to fire a series of bursts while the curtains move across the sensor. This means the flash must fire several times in very quick succession. To have enough power for that many pulses of light, each one must be weaker than a single, high powered burst. Each pulse is dimmer, but because the flash is pulsing many times, the total power used is relatively high in most cases.
Second (Rear) Curtain Sync: Normally the flash fires as soon as the first curtain is completely open. The camera then waits until the set shutter speed has almost elapsed and then begins closing the second curtain. With Rear Curtain Sync, the flash waits and fires just before the second curtain begins to close. The effect this has on moving objects is to make the place they are at the end of the exposure their brightest spot in the frame. The classic example is of a car traveling forward at night. With normal first curtain sync, the flash would fire early in the exposure and the trails of the headlights would extend in front of the car. Using second curtain sync, the flash would fire almost at the end of the exposure and the car would be seen with the light trails behind it. Second Curtain Sync is most effective when used in conjunction with Slow Sync. The amount of power used varies according to the scene.
In each case described above the amount of power used by the flash is determined by how much light the camera needs to properly expose the scene. Any of them might need more or less power depending on the scene.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Flash power is driven more by how much light the flash must add than by the named sync mode itself.
Modes like rear-curtain vs front-curtain mainly change timing, not output, so they don’t inherently save power. Slow sync / slow shutter can reduce the flash’s relative contribution if you use a longer shutter speed and let more ambient light into the exposure. Fill flash often uses low power because it is only lifting shadows rather than lighting the whole scene, but it can still range from very little power to full power depending on conditions.
High-speed sync typically does not save power overall; it uses lower-power pulses repeatedly, which is generally less efficient than normal sync.
So there isn’t a single mode that always uses the least power. In practice, the least flash power is usually achieved when ambient light does most of the work and the flash is only providing fill. If your goal is lower flash output, use more ambient light (for example with a slower shutter in slow sync) and treat the flash as fill rather than main illumination.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can a Metz 58 AF-1 use manual flash power with rear-curtain sync on Pentax bodies and manual lenses?
Does rear-curtain sync increase background exposure in low light?
Can aperture change the fill flash-to-ambient ratio, or is it controlled only by shutter speed?
Does the Fujifilm X100F support second-curtain flash sync?
Why can’t I enable second-curtain sync on my Canon 5D Mark IV with a 600EX II-RT?