Can aperture change the fill flash-to-ambient ratio, or is it controlled only by shutter speed?
Asked 11/8/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I'm confused by a Sekonic fill-flash tutorial. I thought the flash/ambient balance is mainly changed with shutter speed, since a faster shutter reduces ambient light (up to sync speed) while flash exposure is mostly unaffected. But the tutorial seems to show changing aperture to alter the percentage of flash in the final image. Is that wrong, or are they assuming flash power is adjusted first and then camera settings are chosen afterward? How do aperture, shutter speed, and flash power each affect the fill flash-to-ambient ratio?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
3
Notice that step 2 in their process is:
Adjust the flash power output until you have a desired percentage of flash
So before you even touch your camera, you're adjusting the ratio of flash to ambient by changing the power and/or position of the flash and measuring with the meter (remember, this is a tutorial on how to use a flash meter). It's only when the desired ratio has been achieved that you pick up your camera, apply the settings from the meter, and shoot.
it talks about how to control the proportion of fill flash relative to ambient light. In it, they illustrate how by changing aperture you can change this flash/ambient light ratio.
I think you're misunderstanding what they're saying. You're right that you can use aperture to control flash and shutter speed to control ambient. In this case, though, the flash/ambient ratio has already been determined, and you're simply adjusting the camera for proper exposure.
For example, let's say that you've taken a photo that's properly exposed, but you want more flash and less ambient. One way to do that is to bump up the power on the strobe, but that would result in an overexposed photo because the total amount of light is now greater. To compensate, you use a smaller aperture. You can't use a faster shutter speed and maintain the flash/ambient ratio because, as you correctly point out, shutter speed only affects ambient. (Also, you can't increase shutter beyond the flash sync speed without getting into high speed sync, and that affects the available flash power.) You could decrease the ISO setting, but the ISO in the example is already down to 160. Changing the aperture decreases the total light hitting the sensor without affecting the flash/ambient ratio.
Originally by user4262. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4262
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The tutorial is not necessarily wrong; it’s using a different workflow.
With manual flash, the ratio between flash and ambient can be affected by:
- flash power (or flash distance)
- aperture
- shutter speed
- ISO
Key idea:
- Shutter speed mainly affects ambient exposure, because the flash duration is very short.
- Aperture affects both ambient and flash exposure.
So if you change only aperture and keep shutter speed and flash power fixed, both ambient and flash rise together; that alone does not cleanly isolate the ratio.
But in the Sekonic workflow, they first set the desired flash contribution by adjusting flash power/output and measuring it. Then they choose camera settings based on those meter readings. In that context, opening the aperture may require a compensating shutter-speed change, which can alter how much ambient is recorded relative to the already-set flash level.
So your understanding is also valid: a common way to increase flash percentage is to use a faster shutter speed (up to sync speed) to cut ambient while leaving flash exposure mostly the same.
In short: shutter speed is the usual on-camera control for ambient vs flash, while aperture affects both; flash power is the direct control of flash contribution.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Is using a wide aperture with flash common, and why is it harder outdoors?
Why is flash-to-ambient often described in percentages, while main-to-fill is given as a lighting ratio?
Which flash modes generally use the least power?
How do I use a flash meter to set manual off-camera flash for fill with ambient light?
Why doesn’t a longer shutter speed make this Christmas lights photo much brighter?