When should I use TTL vs TTL-BL flash, and how does spot or matrix metering affect them?
Asked 1/11/2012
4 views
2 answers
0
I’m learning Nikon flash and I’m confused about how camera metering mode interacts with flash metering. In particular, when are these combinations most appropriate, and why?
- TTL + spot/center-weighted
- TTL + matrix
- TTL-BL + matrix
(My Nikon D80 with SB-700 does not offer TTL-BL with spot metering.)
I’d like to understand how ambient metering and flash metering relate, and whether spot or matrix changes the flash exposure, the background exposure, or both.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
2
With TTL/iTTL, the ambient and flash metering are independent. So you can use spot or matrix for your background, whatever is most suitable. So you would probably use matrix most of the time unless you have extreme lighting situations where matrix isn't doing the job. Matrix is best if you want any chance of getting the correct background exposure. If you use spot, both the ambient and flash metering will only take into account that one spot and your background will not be considered.
The flash is controlled by a separate metering system which will attempt to correctly expose your subject (I think it uses distance information from the lens, plus preflashes to measure reflected light off the subject).
TTL/iTTL would be used most of the time, except for one specific situation where you use TTL-BL.
TTL-BL (BL=back lit) attempts to balance the light of your subject with a bright background. In this mode, the camera and flash meters are coupled and work together. But it is only meant to be used in back-lit situations.
I would say the combination of TTL-BL + spot/center-weighted is not available because the meter needs the background information to know how to balance the scene. When you use TTL-BL the metering of both ambient and flash is done together. The matrix metering calculates the correct overall exposure, sets aperture, ISO, shutter speed, depending on what mode the camera is in, then also instructs the flash to fill in a certain amount of light which it has judged is needed to brighten the subject appropriately.
So
- TTL + Matrix would be used for most situations
- TTL + spot in extreme lighting situations, or where you really want the subject lit perfectly and are not concerned with the background
- TTL-BL in bright outdoor scenes where your subject is back lit. If TTL-BL does not produce good exposures, then you might switch to TTL + Spot meter
The iTTL system is very smart and usually does a terrific job. But if it's not giving you good results (usually in extremently bright or dim situations), I think the best method is to switch off the flash first, set camera to manual mode, and get the background looking as you want it, with just the ambient light. Then switch on the flash, probably start with minus 1 flash compensation, and adjust the flash compensation until the subject is well lit. The background, which won't be lit much at all by the flash, should remain constant, so you'll get a good balanced image.
There is a complete guide to Nikon CLS here: Nikon CLS Practical Guide
But also see this for an alternative view of how TTL-BL meters from a fellow Kiwi.
Originally by user4191. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4191
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
On Nikon, ambient metering and TTL flash metering are related but not the same job.
- TTL: the flash tries to expose the main subject correctly, largely independent of the camera’s ambient metering mode.
- Spot / center-weighted / matrix: mainly affect how the ambient/background exposure is chosen.
In practice:
- TTL + matrix: best general-purpose choice. Matrix gives the camera the best chance of exposing the overall scene/background sensibly, while TTL handles the subject with flash.
- TTL + spot or center-weighted: use when the background or ambient light is tricky and you want to meter a specific area yourself. Spot metering ignores most of the scene, so background exposure can swing dramatically if you meter the wrong area.
- TTL-BL + matrix: use when you want more natural-looking flash fill balanced with ambient light. TTL-BL is designed to blend flash with the scene, and it works best with matrix metering.
That also explains why TTL-BL + spot is often unavailable: balanced fill flash depends on evaluating the whole scene, which conflicts with spot metering’s very narrow view.
So, for learning and most everyday use: start with TTL + matrix, then move to TTL-BL + matrix for fill-flash situations.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which metering mode works best with AE-L on a Nikon D700?
How does TTL flash decide the “correct” flash power?
Which metering mode should I use when shooting HDR brackets?
How do I switch a Nikon Z7 and SB-300 from i-TTL Balanced Fill to standard i-TTL?
Which metering mode should I use for handheld walk-around photography?