When do straight lines appear curved in wide-angle projections?

Asked 11/7/2017

1 views

2 answers

0

I'm trying to understand perspective and projection when representing a very wide field of view on a flat surface. If I draw a scene with lots of straight architectural lines and keep expanding the view farther around me, at what point do straight lines need to become curved? Are straight lines only preserved in certain kinds of projection? I'm looking for a basic explanation of how flat images represent a spherical field of view, especially for very wide scenes.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

2

When do straight lines become curved when talking about projection?

When you decide what type of projection you wish to use.

A rectilinear projection will preserve straight lines (but not correct angles between straight lines) at the expense of the relative sizes of objects in the center of the frame versus the edge of the frame. Things near the edge will be distorted in size to preserve straight lines. This works best with photographic lenses when the angle of view is relatively narrow. The wider the field of view, the more distorted the angles between straight lines become and the more distorted the relative sizes of things in the center and things on the edges becomes.

A fisheye projection will preserve relative sizes at the expense of not preserving straight lines.

An orthographic projection will preserve both straight lines and the angles between them. To capture an orthographic projection with a camera requires a telecentric lens that is larger in diameter than the width/height of the scene being projected. Many architectural drawings ('side view', 'top view', etc.) use orthographic projection. Each point in the scene is drawn from a constant angle rather than from the perspective of a constant point of view. Scanners and copiers capture an orthographic view of flat documents by travelling across the face of the document as they image each part.

There are many other types of projections, but these are the most common seen within the context of photographic lenses.

In the photographic disciplines (which is the specifically expressed subject of this site) the term projection is used when discussing how a lens projects a 2D image of the 3D world onto a flat imaging plane. In the disciplines related to artistic drawing, the term perspective is used in much the same way. But in the photographic disciplines the term perspective refers not to how an image is projected by a lens, but rather the relative positions of the objects within the camera's angle of view and how the relative distances from the camera to each of those objects affects their relative shapes and sizes as well as what part of a more distant object may be hidden by a closer object. Changing projection will alter the shapes of things, but not what parts are hidden by closer objects. Only changing the camera position, that is the perspective, can change that.

For more, please see:
What is the difference between perspective distortion and barrel or pincushion distortion?
Does wide angle equivalent in crop sensor skew image?
How do i take a photo of an object perfectly vertical like a top view?
Why the faces in the corner tends to skew a bit in almost all smartphone cameras
How wide can a lens be before it begins to produce distortion?
What does it really mean that telephoto lenses "flatten" scenes?
What's the opposite of a fisheye lens?
How can I achieve an effect in still photography that's analogous to a cinematographic effect?

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Straight lines become curved when you choose a projection that does not preserve them.

In a rectilinear projection—the usual idealized photographic perspective—straight lines in the scene stay straight in the image. The tradeoff is increasing distortion of scale and angles toward the edges, especially as the angle of view gets very wide. That’s why extremely wide rectilinear views can look stretched or unnatural near the frame edges.

In a fisheye projection, relative spacing/size across the frame is handled differently, but straight lines are generally not preserved; lines away from the image center often bow into curves. A common exception is that lines passing through the center may remain straight.

So there isn’t a single point where lines must become curved. It depends on the projection method you use and how wide a field of view you want to include on a flat surface.

For understanding the broader theory, cartography is very relevant: mapping a sphere onto a plane faces the same basic problem. Any flat representation of a wide field of view has to compromise somewhere—straightness, angles, scale, or area.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer