What’s the difference between vertical and horizontal focal-plane shutters?
Asked 3/2/2012
7 views
2 answers
0
I’ve seen most modern SLR/DSLR focal-plane shutters described as having vertical-travel curtains, but my Pentax K1000 has a horizontal-travel shutter. What practical differences are there between vertical and horizontal shutters? Do vertical shutters offer advantages for maximum shutter speed or flash sync speed? How does curtain direction affect distortion at very fast shutter speeds, and were horizontal focal-plane shutters mainly used in older film SLRs?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
4
In terms of answers...
The difference is rather obvious and it's not all that dramatic, it's simply direction of travel. Vertical shutters do have an advantage, however, in that is because they have less distance to travel, a third less. That allows for faster flash sync speeds and faster shutter speeds.
At any rate, I think modern dSLR cameras are vertical. I'm not aware of one that is horizontal, but it may exist...
Originally by user472. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user472
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The main difference is simply the direction the shutter curtains travel across the film or sensor.
In practice, vertical-travel shutters usually have a shorter distance to cover than horizontal ones, so they can complete the exposure cycle faster. That’s why vertical shutters are associated with higher maximum shutter speeds and higher flash sync speeds.
Horizontal-travel focal-plane shutters were very common in older film cameras, especially fully mechanical SLRs. Their design fit well with classic film-camera mechanisms, but they generally had lower top shutter speeds and lower sync speeds than later vertical designs.
At shutter speeds faster than X-sync, a focal-plane shutter works as a moving slit rather than fully opening all at once. This means fast-moving subjects can show rolling-shutter-like distortion. The direction of that distortion depends on shutter travel:
- vertical-travel shutter: distortion is most apparent with horizontally moving subjects
- horizontal-travel shutter: distortion is most apparent with vertically moving subjects
So yes, SLRs with horizontal shutters definitely exist—many classic film SLRs used them. Modern DSLRs are generally vertical-travel designs because of the speed and sync advantages.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Which direction do modern focal-plane shutters travel, and why?
Do any focal-plane curtain shutters run in both directions, and does curtain reset limit frame rate?
What limits a camera’s maximum flash sync speed?
Why do focal-plane shutters use a moving slit at fast shutter speeds instead of exposing the whole sensor at once?
Is the maximum fully open shutter speed the same as flash sync speed?