Is the maximum fully open shutter speed the same as flash sync speed?
Asked 12/4/2011
6 views
2 answers
0
For a focal-plane shutter like the Nikon D7000’s, what is the fastest shutter speed at which the sensor is ever completely uncovered by the shutter curtains? Is that effectively the same as the camera’s maximum flash sync speed, or is flash sync usually set a bit slower to allow for flash timing delays and flash duration?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
4
As you suggest the highest speed at which the shutter is at some point fully open will be faster than the quoted flash sync speed, to allow some variation in flash timing, probably just under a stop faster.
I don't have any information for the D7000, but the Canon 1D mkIII has sync speed of 1/250s with most flashes. When a Canon EX flash is used the camera can sync at 1/300s by improving the timing, according to Canon:
"For the X-sync contact, the mechanical contact has been eliminated to prevent contact scorching and wear. By employing PR signals for the electronic X-sync contact (a semiconductor switch), reliability is improved. By optimizing the sync timing, an X-sync speed of 1/300 sec. is now attained with EX series Speedlites. With non-EX Speedlites, the X-sync speed will be 1/250 sec., the same as the EOS-1D Mark II N's."
1/300s is not the limit however, by further tweaking the timing flash timing using a pocketwizard it's reportedly possible to get the 1D mkIII to sync at 1/500s (with barely noticeable letterboxing), according to Rob Galbraith:
"The EOS-1D Mark III, EOS-1D Mark II N and EOS-1D Mark II are the only camera models capable of a nearly-clean 1/500 using the first HyperSync mode, but all Canon cameras will see a one or two step increase in usable shutter sync speed compared to previous PocketWizard transmitters. The bump is greater still when compared to certain other wireless triggering devices."
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In practical terms, yes: the maximum flash sync speed is essentially the fastest shutter speed at which both shutter curtains are fully open at the same time.
With a focal-plane shutter, once you go faster than sync speed, the second curtain begins closing before the first has fully opened, so the sensor is exposed through a moving slit rather than all at once. A normal flash burst would then only light part of the frame.
That said, published sync speed can be a little slower than the absolute mechanical limit. Manufacturers may leave a small safety margin for timing tolerances, trigger delays, and flash behavior. Some systems can sync slightly faster with dedicated flashes because timing is more tightly controlled.
So the best general answer is: the two speeds are effectively the same for real-world use, but the rated flash sync speed may be set slightly below the absolute maximum fully-open shutter speed.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What physically limits a camera’s maximum flash sync speed?
What limits a camera’s maximum flash sync speed?
Do long exposures on a DSLR behave like a global shutter?
What’s the difference between vertical and horizontal focal-plane shutters?
Why is flash sync speed slower than flash duration?