What should I consider when choosing a CompactFlash memory card for a Canon 20D?

Asked 11/16/2013

5 views

2 answers

0

I’m buying a CompactFlash card for a Canon 20D and want to know what matters most when choosing one. I’m mainly wondering about:

  • maximum card capacity the 20D can reliably use
  • whether faster cards provide any benefit in this camera
  • which brands are generally considered reliable
  • whether cold weather is a concern for CF cards
  • any other practical things I should watch out for

I’ve seen claims that larger cards may work if they aren’t formatted in-camera, but I’d prefer the most dependable option.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

3

The Canon 20D topped out at around 6 MB/sec when Rob Galbraith tested many of the cards currently available back in 2006 or so. Considering that the 30D improved to almost 7 MB/sec using many of the same cards, I would say anything over 6 MB/sec is overkill for the 20D. The slowest cards on the market today are faster than that, unless they are unsold older stock.

As far as reliability goes, I've never had a problem with any card from SanDisK, Transcend, or Lexar. My newer cards are all the Transcend brand. I've used them heavily for years. I follow a couple of simple rules: NEVER insert or remove a CF card in a device that is powered on. SD cards and USB drives are designed to be hot swappable if "ejected" properly before removal. The design standards for CF includes no such provision. Also, rather than "erasing all images" from a card, I format the card in the camera in which it will be used.

The design standard for all CF cards is a lot more tolerant of extreme temperatures than other types of flash memory such as SD cards. SanDisk touts the durability of their cards when used in extreme temperatures and at high altitudes. My own experience shooting in sub-freezing weather is that it is a non-issue with any of the cards I own.

In cold environments battery life will be your primary concern. Take at least two and keep one warm with the body heat inside your clothes while you shoot with the other. You can swap them and warm the cold one back up and it will 'recover' some of the energy it lost as it was cooled.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For a Canon 20D, the main factors are capacity, reliability, and practical speed.

Capacity: if the camera is generally regarded as supporting up to about 8GB, staying at or below that is the safest choice. Larger cards may sometimes work with workarounds, but for dependable use it’s best not to rely on that.

Speed: the 20D appears to top out around 6 MB/s write performance, so very fast CF cards won’t make much difference in-camera. Almost any modern CF card should be fast enough for shooting; faster cards help more when copying files with a good card reader.

Brands: the answers consistently point to SanDisk, Lexar, Kingston, and Transcend as reputable choices, with SanDisk and Lexar often mentioned as premium options. Reliability matters more than chasing maximum advertised speed.

Cold weather: no specific card issue stood out from the answers beyond general reliability; reputable cards are usually fine. In real-world use, moisture and handling can be bigger concerns than the card itself.

Practical tip: with CF cards, avoid inserting or removing the card while the device is powered on.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer