What ND filter strength do I need for daytime lightning long exposures?

Asked 2/28/2015

3 views

2 answers

0

I’m new to photography and have managed a decent lightning photo at night using a long exposure. In daytime, though, my exposures are too bright to leave the shutter open long enough to catch lightning. A friend suggested using a neutral density (ND) filter.

I’m shooting with a Canon 600D and the 18–55mm kit lens. Is an ND filter the right approach for daytime lightning, and how do I choose the correct strength?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

2

The differences between ND filters are not necessarily between kinds but rather between values.

The value you should look for is how many f-stops (or in this case shutter speeds) do you want to change.

Let's say the light conditions you are taking the photo in now (9AM, with sunlight, in summer, your iso and aperture well defined) give you a shutter speed of 1/500 and you need a exposure of 1/2 second.

The f-stop difference will be

1/250=1

1/125=2

 1/60=3

 1/30=4

 1/15=5

  1/8=6

  1/4=7

  1/2=8

So you need a filter that reduces the light 8 f-stops.

According to this table http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutral_density_filter you can use a ND108 or N119 filter.

It is not recommended that you stalk too many filters, but probably 2 will be fine, so you can buy for example a 103 and a 106 and combine them to have a 109.

Polarizing filters are helpful and they have an Xx scale to see the f-stop change. A filter that is marked 2x will reduce the f-stop 2 steps.

Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user37321

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—an ND filter is the right tool if you need a longer shutter speed in bright daylight. The key difference between ND filters is their strength, measured in stops of light reduction.

To choose one, first work out your normal exposure in the scene, then compare it to the shutter speed you want. For example, if the scene meters at 1/500s and you want about 1/2s, that’s an 8-stop difference: 1/500 → 1/250 (1) → 1/125 (2) → 1/60 (3) → 1/30 (4) → 1/15 (5) → 1/8 (6) → 1/4 (7) → 1/2 (8).

So in that example, you’d want roughly an 8-stop ND filter. ND filters are often labeled by optical density as well as stops, so look for an ND that gives about 8 stops of reduction.

In short: yes, use an ND filter, and pick the strength based on how many stops you need to slow the shutter in your actual daylight conditions. Stacking too many filters is generally not ideal, but using one or two can be fine.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer