What is the black card technique in photography, and when is it used?
Asked 5/29/2012
3 views
2 answers
0
I’ve seen landscape photos described as using the “black card technique” instead of HDR, graduated ND filters, or exposure blending. What is this technique, how do you do it, and what are its pros and cons?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
38
The Black Card Technique is a workaround for the problem of the limited dynamic range of digital cameras. The dynamic range of a camera describes the difference in light levels it can record.
The limits of dynamic range are often seen in landscape photography - you will often see photos where the sky is nicely exposed, but the ground is underexposed, or vice versa. This is because the camera can't record enough of a range.
The Black Card Technique attempts to get around this problem by essentially allowing two different exposure times in one shot. The card is used to block the brightest part of the image for the majority of the exposure, allowing the darkest part to be exposed properly without overexposing the bright part.
The technique is relatively simple. Simply set your camera up on a tripod, and set it for spot metering. Meter the ground and note the setting given - let's say you're photographing a sunset and the ground reading is 8 seconds. Now meter for the sky, which will give a faster shutter speed - let's say 2 seconds.
Set the camera to Manual and dial in an 8 second exposure, for the ground. Using either the viewfinder or live view, compose the scene and place the card over the lens so that the sky is covered. Fire the shutter and time 6 seconds, then remove the black card for the final 2 seconds.
The ground, which wasn't covered by the card, has now been correctly exposed for 8 seconds, while the sky was covered for 6 seconds and then exposed for 2 seconds, again correctly as per the meter reading. You should therefore have a shot with correct exposure in both the dark and light parts.
The pros of this technique are that it is cheap and relatively simple to achieve. It precludes the need for multiple Neutral Density filters, which are the 'proper' alternative. However, neutral density filters are less fussy to use, offer a range of gradations for a more natural transition from sky to ground (amongst other things), and offer less chance of introducing camera shake by nudging the lens with the card.
Originally by user3205. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user3205
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
The black card technique is an in-camera way to handle scenes with more brightness range than your camera can record in a single normal exposure, especially landscapes with a bright sky and darker foreground.
The idea is simple: during a longer exposure, you briefly block the brightest part of the frame with a black card for part of the exposure time. This reduces exposure in that area while letting the darker parts continue to build exposure, so you effectively create different exposure times within one shot.
It’s often described as in-camera dodging and burning.
Typical use:
- Put the camera on a tripod
- Use a long exposure
- Hold a black card in front of the bright area (without touching the lens)
- Move it away for part of the exposure so the bright region gets less total light than the darker region
Pros:
- Can look more natural than heavy HDR
- Done in-camera, with less post-processing
- Useful when you don’t want to use GND filters
Cons:
- Best for static scenes
- Requires practice and timing
- Works mainly with exposures long enough to manipulate by hand
- Less precise and repeatable than some other methods
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Graduated ND filter vs HDR: which is better for bright skies and darker foregrounds?
Can you stack a circular ND behind a square graduated ND filter holder?
Why use a graduated ND filter instead of adding the effect in software?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of back-illuminated (BSI) CMOS sensors?
How can I create a dramatic backlit landscape with the sun, foreground detail, and HDR processing?