What is a removable black cover on a photography umbrella for?
Asked 8/18/2013
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m new to off-camera flash and looking at light stands and umbrellas. Some umbrellas have a removable black outer cover. Am I right that you leave the cover on when using the umbrella as a reflective bounce umbrella, and remove it when using it as a shoot-through umbrella? If so, what practical difference does that make in the light?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
6
You're correct. When the black covering is on, the umbrella is intended to reflect the light. When the black cover is off, you change the orientation of the umbrella so that your light goes through it instead (shoot through). Your linked item describes that in the product description. It's a handy feature to have (I have a couple of the Paul Buff ones) though can be a bit of a pain to put on and take off versus a dedicated umbrella.
A good comparison of the two options can be seen on Lighting Essentials - Umbrella Comparison but in a nutshell, the shoot through is more contrasty and the bounce wraps the subject more. Worth reading the article to get a sense of the result.
Originally by user472. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user472
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes. A removable black cover lets one umbrella work in two ways:
- cover on: use it as a reflective umbrella, aiming the flash into the umbrella so the light bounces back toward the subject
- cover off: use it as a shoot-through umbrella, aiming the flash through the translucent fabric toward the subject
That makes the umbrella more flexible than a dedicated single-purpose model.
In practice, shoot-through use lets you place the umbrella’s white surface closer to the subject, because the flash sits behind it instead of firing into it from the front. Closer light is usually softer, and the light falloff is faster. Reflective use places the lit surface farther away by roughly the umbrella shaft length, which can change both softness and falloff.
The answers also note a general character difference: shoot-through tends to be more contrasty, while reflective bounce tends to wrap the subject more. The tradeoff is convenience: convertible umbrellas are handy, but swapping the cover on and off can be less convenient than owning separate dedicated umbrellas.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How much light do you typically lose with a photography umbrella?
How does a front diffusion cover change the light from a reflective umbrella?
Shoot-through vs reflective umbrellas for small product photography
Can lighting umbrellas and other light modifiers travel safely in a regular backpack?
What’s the difference between white and silver reflective umbrellas?