What’s the difference between white and silver reflective umbrellas?
Asked 5/14/2021
2 views
2 answers
0
I know gold umbrellas can warm the light. What practical difference is there between white reflective umbrellas and silver reflective umbrellas? Do silver umbrellas change the color temperature, or is the main difference in how the light looks?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
5y ago
2 Answers
8
No, Nothing to do with the temperature. It changes the hardness of the light.
There are two usages of a white umbrella. As a bounced light inside it, or as a fast-setup softbox, passing the light through it. It is definitely a diffuse light.
The difference versus a softbox is that on a softbox you do not spill light all over the place. When using a white umbrella as a bounce light you can add a black cover so the light does not spill behind it, you have still much light all over the place. It is a good option if you want for example high key portraits.
But a silver umbrella is only used as a bounce light. Depending on the overall size, and the position of the flash inside it, it can produce different results.
One example is parabolic umbrellas. If the umbrella is a real parabolic one, (big umbrellas and specialized brands) can give you more or less parallel rays, where the fall-off of the light is lower than a normal studio light. The light should be on the focal point.
But a white one will spill more light, regardless of the shape of the umbrella.
In general, is due to the nature of how light is bounced on different surfaces.
The diagrams are exaggerated, especially the silver ones.
That would be a perfect mirror, like a chromed metallic surface. The finish of silver umbrellas has some diffusion but not as much as white.
Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user37321
5y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Silver umbrellas generally do not change color temperature in any meaningful way. The main difference between white and silver umbrellas is the quality of light.
A white umbrella produces more diffuse light, which gives softer shadows. White umbrellas can often be used two ways: as a bounce umbrella or as a shoot-through diffuser, making them very versatile. They also tend to spread light more broadly, which can be useful for soft, even lighting.
A silver umbrella is typically used only as a bounce umbrella. It reflects light more directly, which usually creates a crisper, less diffuse result with harder shadows than a white umbrella. The exact look also depends on the umbrella’s size and how the flash is positioned inside it.
So in short: white = softer, more diffused light; silver = punchier, harder light. Gold is the one commonly used to warm the light.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI5y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Does a flash umbrella change the color temperature of your light?
How far can human vision adapt to different color temperatures?
Softboxes vs shoot-through and reflective umbrellas for portrait lighting
What is a black reflector used for in photography?
How can I adjust color temperature in Photoshop Elements?

