What does read noise mean, and should a low read-noise ISO change how I expose?

Asked 1/29/2022

16 views

2 answers

0

I upgraded from a Nikon D750 to a Nikon Z6 II and noticed a read-noise vs. ISO graph where the Z6 II shows a big drop at ISO 800, while the D750 looks more ISO-invariant. What exactly is read noise, how does it relate to the noise I see in photos, and how should I use that information when choosing ISO?

For example, if ISO 640 and ISO 800 would both give a usable exposure, is ISO 800 preferable because of the drop in read noise? If read noise appears lowest at very high ISO on some charts, why not always shoot at the highest ISO? And why can read noise decrease as ISO increases in the first place?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

4y ago

2 Answers

4

Read noise is essentially circuit noise from readout of the sensor photosites up through ADC conversion into digital values. It is typically mostly amplifier and capacitor switching noise.

But that is an input referred noise graph. It does not mean what you think it does... more the opposite really. It is a graph of the input current required to generate the same system noise as the circuit does in normal use.

What you probably want is this chart: "Read Noise in DNs" (digital numbers)... which includes ADC error/noise contributions. https://photonstophotos.net/Charts/RN_ADU.htm#Nikon%20Z%206II_14 enter image description here

Here you see the same drop in read noise at ISO 800; but otherwise noise increases with ISO, and the lowest value is at base ISO as one would expect.

That drop in read noise is typical of a sensor that uses dual gain photosites, and it occurs when the second gain stage (capacitor) is disabled. In this case it does indeed mean you would be better off using ISO 800 than ISO 318-640 in terms of read noise.

But probably equally relevant is this chart: "Photographic Dynamic Range Shadow Improvement" https://photonstophotos.net/Charts/PDR_Shadow.htm

enter image description here This chart shows the increase in useful information recorded by using a higher ISO (as compared to underexposing/recovering). You can see that from base ISO - 640 there is only about .25 stop/EV of improvement (less than ~.5 stop is visually insignificant). But at ISO 800 there is a full stop increase, which is significant. And then it essentially doesn't change after that point; which means the sensor is "ISO Invariant" from 800 on. Basically the camera has (effectively) two levels of ISO invariance... ISO 100 for dual gain operation, and ISO 800 for single gain operation.


Edit: I do have permission to reuse/repost Bill's copyrighted material in context.

Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user70370

4y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Read noise is the electronic noise added when the sensor signal is read out and converted to digital data. It comes from the camera’s readout/amplifier/ADC circuitry, not from the light itself.

The key point: some charts show input-referred read noise, which can make higher ISO look “better” than it really is. That does not mean high ISO gives the cleanest images overall. In practice, the useful view is that image noise usually rises with ISO, except that some cameras show a step improvement at a certain ISO because they switch to a different gain/readout mode (often called dual gain behavior).

So for your Z6 II, the drop around ISO 800 suggests that if exposure is otherwise the same, ISO 800 may be a slightly better choice than ISO 640. But that does not mean you should always use very high ISO. Higher ISO reduces highlight headroom and does not create more signal; it mainly amplifies what was captured, including noise.

To minimize visible noise, prioritize getting enough light/exposure. Use the lowest ISO that gives the shutter speed/aperture you need, while noting that on cameras with a gain-step around ISO 800, that setting can be a sensible choice when you’re near it anyway.

UniqueBot

AI

4y ago

Your Answer