What diffuser material can even out a multi-LED flashlight beam for photography?

Asked 6/2/2020

2 views

2 answers

0

I’m experimenting with a compact lighting setup for photographing textures. The light source is a very bright multi-LED flashlight used about 1–3 m from the subject, and the beam is uneven because the individual LEDs create visible hot spots. I’d like to cut a circular diffuser to mount on the light, ideally using a material that can tolerate extended use (around 20–30 minutes) and lose as little output as possible. Are stage/film diffusion sheets such as Rosco or LEE a good starting point, or is a more durable option like white diffused acrylic better?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

2

In addition to the Rosco kit you mentioned it might also be worth taking a look at LEE filters. They offer a visual comparison of their diffusion materials.

There is also a quite useful comparison of different bounce and diffusion materials by Matt Porwoll.

While these demonstrations are mainly intended for larger-scale photographic and cinematographic use, they should give you an idea of how they will perform in your situation. For starters a filter set with some ranges of white diffusion and frost will get you started and it's useful to have them in general.

There's also white diffuse acrylic glass, which would probably be a more durable solution.

Be aware though that the relative size of your light source will influence the characteristics of your lighting, so you should make sure that the 20-30cm diameter is sufficient for your subject (as a rule of thumb, to achieve „soft“ lighting your light source should be at least the size of the area you intend to light, and that's assuming you are up pretty close to the subject. Usually you'd want to move away from the subject to reduce light falloff, which means you'd need to scale up your light source as well to achieve the same shadow characteristics).

As a side node, in still photography you might get higher light output from a flash.

Originally by user45760. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user45760

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Rosco or LEE diffusion sheets are a sensible place to start. A small kit with white diffusion and frost materials lets you test how much smoothing you get versus how much light you lose. LEE also provides visual comparisons of their diffusion types, which can help you choose.

A more durable option is white diffused acrylic, which may hold up better physically than gel sheets.

The tradeoff is unavoidable: diffusion works by scattering light so the LED sources mix together, but that also spreads the beam and lowers intensity. Expect at least about 1 stop of light loss, and possibly more, if you want noticeably more even illumination. Diffusion also makes light less hard, which can reduce contrast in textures.

So yes, a Rosco diffusion kit is worth trying as an experiment. If maximum durability matters, diffused acrylic is another good option. If your main goal is to keep output concentrated while smoothing the beam, a textured reflector or a beam-shaping lens/filter may work better than heavy diffusion alone.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer