What causes large white spots and streaks on developed medium-format negatives?
Asked 10/12/2019
6 views
2 answers
0
I shot Ilford HP5 Plus in a Mamiya 645 1000s and developed it in a Paterson tank using Ilford DD-X 1+4, stop bath, and fixer. After scanning on an Epson V800 with SilverFast 8, I noticed many large white spots and some streaky bands, especially in skies. Some marks look like ordinary dust, but others appear as stripes or clusters of white dots across the frame. Similar issues later appeared on other rolls as well. What are the likely causes, and how can I tell whether this is dust, a scanning problem, development/agitation issue, or a film defect?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
2
These spots seem like typical dust spots. I encounter them regularly and are usually quite easy to remove in Lightroom or Photoshop. In the darkroom, it is more of a hassle. After meticulous dust removal pre-exposure, dust may still show (significant) spots on the print. Here, retouch kits are used.
You won't ever get rid of dust. You worded it nicely, it's a true plague. Depending on how the film was handled and stored, you'll get more or less dust, and the distribution can also vary between frames. There are however a few methods of reducing the amount of dust in your scans and prints:
- If you develop film yourself, let the film dry in usually humid area such as the bathroom. The humid air catches a lot of the dust that's floating freely in the air and lets it settle on the ground, so it won't fall on your film.
- Use pressurised air canisters to blow the dust from the film strips and scanner glass. Alternatively, you can use hand-powered dust blowers.
- Use microfiber cloths to wipe the strips and glass clean. Static free cloths are a good option. I know Ilford uses or used to sell them.
If you are unsure whether you are dealing with dust or other artefacts, it is always useful to resort back to the negatives or positives. Check these for spots, this may help you in figuring out what is causing the artefacts you are seeing.
EDIT
The streaking you are referring to seems like slight bromide drag. Bromide drag can happen when the bromide in the film emulsion overpowers the developing agent. Solutions: either properly invert the tank when developing (so don't use the rotating stick), or use a stronger developer solution.
Originally by user83099. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user83099
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
There appear to be two different issues.
First, at least some of the small white spots are simply dust. Dust on negatives or in the scanner commonly shows up as white marks, and medium-format scans make it very visible. Careful cleaning and dust control help, but you never eliminate it completely.
Second, the streaky bands/clusters are probably not ordinary dust. If those bands are visible only in the scan, they may be a scanning artifact. If they are actually on the negative, uneven development from insufficient agitation can cause streakiness or banding.
However, based on the follow-up you shared, Ilford indicated your processing did not appear to be the trigger and suggested the problem may relate to affected 120 film batches and/or heat exposure. Since it happened on multiple rolls, a film issue is a strong possibility.
So the most likely breakdown is:
- isolated white specks = dust
- broader streaky/banded marks = scan artifact, uneven agitation, or defective/heat-affected film
To diagnose, inspect the negatives directly with a loupe or light table. If the marks are on the film, it’s not just the scanner.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What causes tiny white pinholes on scanned Kodachrome 35mm slides?
What causes fine vertical lines on a C-41 negative?
What causes small white spots on black-and-white negatives, and how can I prevent them?
Why do my Praktica IV film photos have random white spots and scratches?
How can I color-manage a scanner and monitor to capture cyanotypes accurately?