Should I keep my Pentax K20D kit, and is a Canon 60D or 7D the better upgrade?
Asked 10/18/2010
3 views
2 answers
0
I currently use a Pentax K20D with a Tamron 18-250mm. I like the camera, but I’ve become frustrated with its low-light performance, limited tethered shooting support, and the cost/availability of lenses locally.
I’m considering switching to Canon and have three related questions:
- Should I keep my Pentax kit as a second system or sell it?
- Is a Pentax K20D + 18-250mm likely to be worth selling used?
- If I switch, which body makes more sense for general-purpose work: Canon 50D, 60D, or 7D?
I shoot a mix of exterior/interior property photos, portraits, basic product shots, and I’d like to experiment with night photography. Tethered shooting is also important for some clothing/product work. My budget can stretch to a 7D if it’s truly worth it.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
10
On switching systems:
- K-r and K-5 have greatly improved autofocus over the K-7 and earlier generations, both continuous and low-light. That said, 7D is class leading in continuous, and it's unlikely either will come close to the 7D's AF.
- Since the K-x, Pentax really stepped up their ISO performance. K-r and K-5 look to be stellar. 7D/60D is a bit better than K-x (both being much better than the K-7 and K20D), but K-r and K-5 look to be significantly better than the K-x.
- Pentax does not seem to care about tethering, so I wouldn't expect it from them in the near future. If this is a requirement, switch.
- Local dealers probably won't be selling Pentax, so if this is the ease you are referring to, I don't think it will improve.
- You can, however, rent Pentax lenses from CameraLensRentals
- Price of lenses to me seems comparable, with some cheaper and some more expensive than Canon.
- Their DA* lenses and limited primes are similar in quality to the L-series glass and cheaper
- Pentax does not have specialty glass in production (super telephotos, etc)
- Cheaper third party lenses get the benefit of in-body IS on Pentax, making it a better bargain
- You can adapt Pentax lenses to Canon (albeit losing functionality)
- Pentax cameras, IMO, have the best ergonomics in their class and UI. I am not a fan of Canon's ergonomics and choice of front and rear dial, nor their menu system. Try them out in a store and see if it bothers you. Have not personally held the 7D.
To get an idea of what price you may fetch, check out pentaxforums.com. Unfortunately, many K20D owners are upgrading to the K-5, so it will be harder to get a good price for it. Prices range, I think, from $450 to $600. On the other hand, the 18-250mm is out of production, so it's fetching anywhere from $350 to $400+
As for 50D/60D/7D, depends on what you are looking for.
50D's only advantages on the 60D are build, lens-specific AF adjust, which is useful if you use lenses with very shallow DoF, and slightly faster fps.
60D/7D have a significantly improved sensor, among a bunch of other general things. While the 60D has a flip screen, the 7D is a serious camera with awesome AF performance, fps, build, WR, viewfinder, etc. What do you want to do with your camera?
Originally by user389. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user389
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
If tethered shooting is a real requirement, switching from Pentax makes sense—Pentax was not known for strong tethering support here.
Between the Canon bodies, the 50D is generally the weakest option in this comparison; the real choice is 60D vs 7D. The 60D is viewed as an improvement over the 50D overall, while the 7D is the stronger body if you can afford it, especially for autofocus and all-around performance. The 60D and 7D share the same sensor, so image quality is not the main differentiator.
On the Pentax side, newer Pentax bodies improved a lot over the K20D in autofocus and high-ISO performance, but lens availability locally and tethering may still remain concerns.
A sensible approach is to keep the Pentax kit for now, avoid investing more in that system, and sell it only if a good buyer comes along. That lets you continue using it in the meantime and put your money toward a Canon body and lens setup.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can Pentax K-mount lenses be used on a Canon EOS 90D with an adapter?
Should I upgrade from the Canon 650D kit lens for landscapes, or improve technique first?
Canon 550D: replace the 18-55 kit lens with an 18-200mm, or add the 55-250mm for more reach?
Which Canon 60D lenses and accessories will work on a 6D Mark II?
When is tethered shooting useful, and when is a simple remote release enough?