Should I buy a DSLR or a superzoom point-and-shoot for indoor family photos and occasional long zoom?
Asked 10/7/2011
3 views
2 answers
0
I'm an amateur photographer upgrading from a Nikon Coolpix. My main use will be photographing my one-year-old daughter indoors, so I need good low-light image quality, fast response, and the ability to catch movement. I also sometimes want strong zoom reach for distant subjects like birds on buildings.
I'm comparing a DSLR with kit lens versus a high-end superzoom point-and-shoot. I'm confused about a few things:
- Is a DSLR really much better indoors than an expensive point-and-shoot?
- For moving kids, which matters more: high FPS burst rate, autofocus speed, or shutter lag?
- Is the long zoom on a superzoom camera more useful than the short kit lens on a DSLR?
- Why do DSLR lenses usually use focal length numbers instead of advertising "10x" or "30x" zoom?
- Which type is likely to give better HD video?
I understand that with a DSLR I may eventually need additional lenses, so budget matters too.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
6
Based on your requirements a DSLR is necessary.
The main point is your focus on indoor photography, this requires at least a large sensor camera, so either a DSLR or SLD. No point-and-shoot gets close to those in terms of performance, although you may have seen very expensive fixed-lens cameras like the Fuji X100 which can do it, but that one has NO zoom.
The second point is speed. There three parts to this:
- Shutter-lag which is the time the camera takes to respond to you pressing the button. DSLRs lead here by a wide margin and this is probably most important when shooting kids because it lets you capture a precise moment.
- Autofocus speed. This is the time it takes for the camera to focus on your subject. Again DSLRs focus faster than all point-and-shoots.
- Continuous shooting. This is the speed at which images are shot continuously and where CMOS-based point-and-shoots lead by a huge margin. The top DSLR shoots at 11 FPS while the top P&S can do 60 FPS.
Understandably you are concerned by the lack of zoom. Zoom is not part of a DSLR but a property of its lens. The good thing is that it can be bought incrementally. Now, you can get a DSLR with a prime lens (no zoom at all) which is best for low-light and speed and buy zooms as you go along and can afford it.
Modern DSLRs have awesome video quality. Even though some can focus automatically while filming, doing so is poor (slow, noisy and disturbing). You really should learn to focus manually while filming. The shallow depth-of-field gives a cinematic feel but that also means that focus needs far more attention.
The only intermediate solution is to get an Sony SLT camera, like the SLT-A55, that takes interchangeable lenses, uses the same sensor as a DSLR but focuses much faster while filming. It also shoots continuously at 10 FPS with restrictions (or 7 FPS without).
Originally by user1620. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1620
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For your priorities, a DSLR or other large-sensor interchangeable-lens camera is the better fit. Indoor photography strongly favors a larger sensor, which gives better image quality in low light than a typical point-and-shoot superzoom.
For photographing a child, FPS is only one part of speed. More important are shutter lag and autofocus speed, and DSLRs generally outperform point-and-shoots in both. That usually matters more than a headline 10 FPS burst mode.
The tradeoff is zoom convenience. A superzoom gives lots of reach in one package, but it gives up image quality and speed, especially indoors. An interchangeable-lens system is more flexible long term, but you may need another lens later if distant subjects become important.
"10x" or "30x" zoom only describes the ratio between widest and longest focal length, not how much reach it has in absolute terms, so DSLR lenses are usually described by focal length instead.
If portability is your top priority and you won't carry a larger camera, a point-and-shoot may be better than leaving a DSLR at home. But if image quality and responsiveness matter most, choose the DSLR/system camera.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Should I get the 18-55mm kit lens, the 55-250mm, or both for a Canon Rebel T6i?
What superzoom lenses are available for Sony NEX and Samsung NX, and do any reach 27–810mm equivalent?
Nikon D3100 vs D5100 for a first DSLR, and should I buy the kit lens?
Can a DSLR do microscope-level magnification, and what lens setup is needed?
Which of these cameras is best for photographing wild birds?