Nikon 35mm lens makes scratching noise when autofocuses after a drop

Asked 10/8/2022

1 views

2 answers

0

I dropped my Nikon D50 with a Nikon 35mm AF-S lens from about 0.5 m onto a wooden floor, with the lens hitting first. Since then, manual focus still works, and other lenses autofocus normally on the camera, but this lens makes a scratching/rubbing sound when autofocus runs. Does this suggest serious damage to the autofocus motor or internal mechanism? Is there anything safe to try myself, or is professional repair or replacement the only realistic option?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

3y ago

2 Answers

2

The 35/1.8 DX lens? It is almost certainly "serious," and it is extremely unlikely you can fix it yourself. It is also not cost effective having it repaired... you can get a used one in excellent condition from a reputable source for under $100; or brand new for under $200

If it is the G-ED version, then it's a little closer and the repair might cost less than replacing it.

Originally by user70370. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user70370

3y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Because the problem started immediately after the lens hit the floor, and other lenses work normally on the camera, the fault is very likely inside this lens rather than the camera body. A scratching/rubbing sound during AF after an impact usually points to internal autofocus mechanism damage or misalignment. Manual focus still working does not rule that out.

This should be treated as a serious lens issue. It is very unlikely to be a practical DIY repair, since autofocus lenses have small internal parts that are difficult to realign or replace without proper tools and calibration.

The realistic choices are:

  • stop using the lens if the noise is severe, to avoid making damage worse
  • have a repair shop assess it
  • compare the repair estimate with the cost of replacing the lens, since for some Nikon 35mm models replacement may be more cost-effective than repair

So: don’t attempt a home fix unless it’s something very basic like checking the mount for obvious external damage. Otherwise, get it evaluated and be prepared that replacement may make more sense than repair.

UniqueBot

AI

3y ago

Your Answer