Monopod vs tripod for night photography with a Nikon D5100
Asked 8/20/2013
3 views
2 answers
0
I’m deciding between a monopod and a tripod for night photography with a Nikon D5100 and 18-105mm lens. I know night shots often need slower shutter speeds, so a tripod seems like the better choice, but I find tripods heavier and less comfortable to carry. How much benefit does a monopod actually provide at night, and when would it make sense to choose one instead of a tripod? I’m mainly looking for an affordable option.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
6
Although I've used a monopod in a pinch (because I had a monopod with me and didn't have a tripod), the only real way to go for night photography unless you are shooting in a place very well lit with artificial light is a tripod. In general I've found a monopod buys about three or four stops slower than the 1/(focal length X crop factor) rule for non-stabilized lenses. For stabilized lenses the monopod will help extend whatever benefit the Image Stabilization, Vibration Reduction, etc. by another couple of stops or so. A good tripod, on the other hand, will allow you to take much longer shots than a monopod. For me the primary benefit of a monopod is supporting the weight of a heavy lens during an extended shoot such as a sporting event or air show, not to allow longer shutter speeds. For that you really need a tripod. The other use case for a monopod is when you are in places that do not allow tripods but do allow monopods.
This shot was taken from a monopod at 1/5 sec, f/3.5, 35mm focal length, ISO 1600. The lens used was a non-stabilized Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8 L mounted on a Canon EOS 5D mark II. I was shooting a little over three stops below the 1/focal length rule. I had used my longer lens and a 7D on the monopod all afternoon at an air show. Not being aware there was going to be fireworks after dark, I had left my tripod in the car quite a distance from the venue. It is not razor sharp as there appears to have either been a little camera movement or the manual focus left the foreground a little soft. Fortunately, the fireworks in the picture are very forgiving since they are very short bursts of bright light for any single spot in the photo.

This image, on the other hand, was exposed for 30 seconds and would not have been possible without a tripod or other solid camera support. There may be someone that could hold a monopod motionless for 30 seconds, but I've never met anyone that can.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For night photography, a tripod is usually the right tool. A monopod can help a little, but not nearly as much as a tripod for the long exposures often needed at night.
Based on the community feedback, a monopod may buy you only a couple of stops of extra hand-holdability, sometimes a bit more, especially if your lens has stabilization/VR. But it still allows movement in multiple directions, so it won’t keep the camera steady for exposures that run into several seconds or longer.
A tripod, by contrast, can support the much longer shutter speeds commonly used for night scenes, often making shots possible that a monopod simply cannot.
The main advantage of a monopod is not long-exposure stability — it’s reducing fatigue and supporting heavier gear during extended shooting, such as sports or wildlife. With a D5100 and 18-105mm, that benefit is less important than it would be with a large telephoto lens.
If your main goal is night photography, choose a tripod. If weight is the issue, look for a lighter travel tripod rather than replacing it with a monopod.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can the Hama Star 61 tripod support a Nikon DSLR for night photography?
How slow a shutter speed can you use with a monopod, and should image stabilization stay on?
When is a monopod better than a tripod?
How much stability does a monopod add, and should image stabilization stay on?
Nikon D90 vs D5100 as a first DSLR