Nikon D90 vs D5100 as a first DSLR

Asked 6/24/2011

7 views

2 answers

0

I’m buying my first Nikon DSLR and I’m deciding between the Nikon D90 and D5100. In my area, the D90 costs about $250 more. Is the D90 worth the extra money, or is the D5100 the better choice for a beginner? I’m interested in general photography and would also like to understand the trade-offs in image quality, handling, features, and lens compatibility.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

9

Tough choice, especially considering the D90 is still more expensive where you are (its actually cheaper than a D5100 in the USA). D90 is typically considered more of a 'prosumer' model and the D5100 would be perhap, 'high end consumer', but they're from different generations - so things get interesting.

  • The D90 offers a more professional body with more external controls, a in-body focus motor, and a larger, brighter viewfinder.

  • The D5100 has a newer, better sensor (especially in low light), better video mode, higher resolution, and an articulating LCD.

  • The pure image quality of the D5100 is much better than the D90, especially at low light, but the D90 is easier to operate and use in the long run.

  • If you're planning on doing any video, I'd probably go ahead and get the D5100 since its more geared for that.

  • If lens price is going to be a big factor, the D90 has an inbody focus motor which will allow you to autofocus with AF lenses instead of just AF-S lenses - MUCH cheaper to buy AF lenses, but they're slower on autofocus.

Only you can decide if the points above make it 'worth it' or not to you.

Originally by user1917. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1917

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Both are good starter DSLRs, but they suit different priorities.

Choose the D5100 if you want the newer sensor, better image quality, especially in low light, higher resolution, better video, and the articulating screen. If video matters at all, the D5100 is the stronger pick.

Choose the D90 if you value handling and direct controls more than sensor improvements. It has a sturdier, more advanced body, larger/brighter viewfinder, more external buttons and dual control dials, a top LCD, depth-of-field preview, and an in-body autofocus motor that gives broader compatibility with older AF lenses.

In short: D5100 for image quality and video; D90 for ergonomics and enthusiast features. For a first DSLR, many beginners will get more immediate benefit from the D5100’s newer sensor, while photographers who want more manual control and room to grow may prefer the D90.

Also, lens choice matters a lot. A slightly cheaper body with a better lens can be the smarter long-term investment.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer