Is the Sigma 12-24mm a good wide-angle choice for interior architecture on a Canon 70D?
Asked 4/20/2015
4 views
2 answers
0
I’m shooting interior architectural photos with a Canon 70D (APS-C) and have a chance to buy a Sigma 12-24mm full-frame ultra-wide lens at a good price. Since the 70D has a crop sensor, I know the field of view will be narrower than on full frame. Would this still be a strong option for interiors, and what effective focal range should I expect on the 70D?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
1
The Sigma 12-24 is a full frame lens. On a crop sensor camera like the 70D, it will have similar field of view as a (12 x 1.6= ) 19.2 to (24 x 1.6= ) 38.4 mm lens.
You might compare this to shots taken with other lenses near this full-frame length. Comparing this to an 18-55 might help, as you will get a sense of the middle range of the Sigma lens on the wide side. (18 is between 12 and 24).
In my experience, the widest that is really useful on a crop sensor is 10mm. Beyond that the distortion gets severe enough that it is difficult to correct in Photoshop. This is from personal experience, where I have found it quite difficult to control distortion in taking shots. Not impossible, just difficult. Of course, on a full frame camera, 9 and 10mm are often even more distorted.
Here are two examples, outdoor architectural shots, captured at 10mm with a Sigma 10-22mm, on a Canon 40D. They are of similar subjects, buildings in Rome. However, in the first, the camera is angled up, creating significant distortion. The second is camera level, which reduces distortion.


It is also important to compose carefully, as tall objects at the edge of the frame will be more noticeably distorted.

Therefore, IMHO, if you manage your composure correctly, your 12-24 will be quite useful.
Originally by user4880. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user4880
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, it can work well on a Canon 70D, but remember the APS-C crop changes the field of view. A 12-24mm lens on the 70D gives roughly the same angle of view as a 19-38mm lens on full frame (multiply by 1.6).
That means it will still be wide, but not as dramatically wide as it would be on a full-frame body. For interior architecture, that may be fine, and one community member reported the Sigma 12-24 performed very well on an APS-C Canon body.
The main tradeoff is perspective and distortion management: ultra-wide lenses can make composition tricky, and at very wide settings distortion can become harder to control in post-processing. Careful camera positioning is important, especially for interiors.
So if the price is good, it can be a useful lens on the 70D. Just don’t expect the full-frame 12mm look. If your goal is the widest possible view on APS-C, compare it against lenses designed specifically for crop sensors in the 10mm range as well.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What wide-angle lens options make sense on a Canon 550D if I plan to switch to full frame later?
How can I straighten a curved shoreline from an ultra-wide lens shot?
Which panoramic head size makes more sense for shooting interior 360 virtual tours?
What is the widest rectilinear lens for Canon full-frame DSLRs, and can adapters make it wider?
How do I compare wide-angle lenses on full frame, and when would I choose 14mm, 24mm f/1.4, or 24mm f/2.8?