Is a touchscreen laptop worth it for photo editing?
Asked 10/17/2016
4 views
2 answers
0
I’m choosing a new laptop and want to know whether a touchscreen is genuinely useful for photo editing, as an additional input method rather than the only way to work. My workflow is mostly RAW editing in Darktable/Lightroom-style software, with only occasional spot removal and very little brush work. Is a touchscreen likely to improve editing, or is it more of a gimmick compared with a mouse, trackpad, stylus, or graphics tablet?
Originally by user50888. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user50888
9y ago
2 Answers
8
This really depends on what you mean by "touch screen" and "image editing" as well as your own workflow and efficiency.
I've been a Photoshop user for more than 20 years. I could use a Cintiq or other touch screen option IN ADDITION to a desktop/laptop to see directly on the drawing surface what I'm working on.
However, the many 2-in-1 options are very poorly designed for professional usage. Lenovo and Microsoft for example lose all access to keyboards when in drawing tablet mode. To make matters worse unlike Cintiq which offers buttons on the side at least neither Lenovo or Microsoft has any so you can't even setup a few hotkeys. There's nothing! Zooming in and out, undo, switching tools, all of it has to be by pressing menu or panel options.
Now if you're only using Lightroom than this isn't as big of an issue. You'll be a little slower on say flagging and rating but the rest isn't too bad. If you're doing work in something like Photoshop or Affinity Photo though forget it.
Stick to Cintiq or just an Intuous Pro connected to a more traditional desktop or laptop. You might also look at Wacom's ExpressKey Remote but even that for me is limited when I know and use hundreds of shortcuts.
I would encourage you to find the nearest Microsoft store to you and try out a Surface or Lenovo. The one by me at least had a few loaded with Adobe CC so shoppers could try it. For your every day shopper that has no idea what they're doing its a fun gimmick in a shop getting to play in Photoshop right on the screen. But for a Professional Workflow the efficiency just isn't there without key strokes.
Update if you mean a touch screen that isn't a tablet. That's also a gimmick that would find use for maybe Lightroom and not much else. The entire point for editing work of a touch display is having pressure sensitivity for masking, airbrushing, painting, etc. You'll be much better off using an Intuous Pro connected to a non-touch laptop/desktop if that's what you're referring to.
So really my answer is the same for touch screens as it is for 2 in 1s but for different reasons. Touch Screen lacks precision and sensitivity, 2 in 1's lack keyboard while in tablet mode.
Originally by user27243. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user27243
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For most laptop-based photo editing, a touchscreen is usually more gimmick than advantage. Community experience suggests it can be less accurate than a mouse or stylus, gets covered in fingerprints, and is awkward to use on a conventional laptop because the keyboard and screen angle get in the way.
It may help a bit for direct manipulation in some workflows, especially if you like tapping controls or doing occasional localized edits, but it’s generally not a big benefit for RAW editing apps like Darktable or Lightroom-style work. For precise tasks, your fingertip is much less accurate than a stylus, mouse, or graphics tablet.
If you do more brush-based or retouching work, a pen display or graphics tablet can be much more useful than a basic touchscreen laptop. Some 2-in-1 designs also become less efficient in tablet mode because you lose easy access to keyboard shortcuts and dedicated buttons, which slows down common actions like zoom, undo, and tool switching.
Bottom line: a touchscreen can be a nice extra, but it usually shouldn’t be a deciding factor for photo editing. Prioritize display quality, performance, and input devices like a mouse, stylus, or graphics tablet instead.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does Lightroom CC lag with a Wacom Bamboo tablet during click-and-drag tools?
Why can a Wacom tablet be better than a mouse for photo retouching?
Can an Android tablet be used to control Darktable sliders on a Linux laptop?
What graphics tablet works well with Lightroom 5 on a PC for a beginner?
Can Lightroom use a true healing brush, or only spot healing?