In UFRaw, what are the base curve and correction curve used for?
Asked 11/23/2010
2 views
2 answers
0
I understand curves in general from editors like Photoshop or GIMP, and I’d like to do as much tonal adjustment as possible during RAW conversion in UFRaw. But UFRaw has two different curves and I’m not sure when to use each one.
According to the manual, the base curve is applied to each color channel after exposure and white balance, but before gamma correction, on linear data. The correction curve is applied later to the luminosity channel in Lch(ab) space.
What practical difference does that make? When I want to change the overall look of a RAW photo, which curve should I use for which kind of adjustment?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
5
The Base curve is used to alter how the raw light data is interpreted. You can think of this almost as the input curves in other apps, they control how the raw data in the file gets pulled into the image editing space. This is often where fancy curves are used to simulate different types of film and such... that's very much what it's doing, adjusting the response of the film to the light; only digitally.
The Corrections curves are used more to control how the image is rendered out to the destination. This is very much more like varying the type of paper you're printing on. (especially in the B+W paper world.) Since this is just the raw conversion step on the way into gimp, that analogy breaks down a little... maybe it's more like how your film is developed into a negative.
In theory, both curves are capable of the same things. In reality, because of where they arrive in the pipeline, if you're doing ANY other changes with other tools in there, you probably want to do your adjustments with the Base curve, so that those other adjustments are applied after your curves.
disclaimer, I've not used ufraw in a long while, and the above is from memory.
THAT SAID... personally, I would only apply curves in the input process to do very basic adjustments, or to perform camera correction. For example, I have a Canon 20D, it's known to over blow red and under count green... so the camera correction for it very subtly corrects those two flaws. There are actually a number of curves for it from Canon... one for "natural", one for "technically accurate" etc... they've done testing in the lab and built profiles to do very specific things. I typically apply those at import just to normalize the image so that I know the image I'm working on is not tainted by what camera it was taken with. Once I have the image in my editing app (LightRoom for me, Gimp for you) THEN I use artistic curves to adjust the image to the way I want artistically. Why? typically the raw converteres aren't built for artistic play and undo/redo experimentation... they are built to convert raw to something editable, with a minimal adjustment to correct for the deficiencies of the camera.
Originally by user1872. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1872
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Use them for different stages of the conversion.
Base curve: this affects the RAW data early, on the linear image data, and on each color channel equally. Think of it as shaping the camera/film response before the image is fully rendered. It’s the place for broad tonal rendering choices, such as changing the overall contrast response or applying a camera-style or film-like tone curve.
Correction curve: this is applied later, to the image’s luminosity channel. It’s more like a finishing adjustment to the rendered image, used to fine-tune contrast, black point, and overall brightness distribution without directly reshaping the RAW channel response.
In practice:
- Use base curve for the foundational look of the RAW conversion.
- Use correction curve for final tonal tweaks, contrast, and black-point adjustment.
If you’re unsure, start with the base curve for global tone shaping, then use the correction curve sparingly to refine the result. The embedded camera curve options only matter if your RAW file contains such metadata; otherwise, you can ignore that and use UFRaw’s own controls.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I change which modules Darktable applies automatically to RAW files?
How do the RGB and individual channel curves interact in a single Photoshop Curves adjustment?
How can I disable darktable's automatic processing on RAW files?
How can I manually access hidden base curve presets in darktable 2.4?
Can a TIFF file tell you what gamma correction was applied?