How was the curved water splash in Philippe Halsman’s “Dali Atomicus” created?

Asked 8/15/2012

8 views

2 answers

0

I’m trying to recreate the look of the water splash in Philippe Halsman’s “Dali Atomicus.” What puzzles me is the shape of the water: instead of a simple downward arc, it seems to curve upward, then flatten, then dip slightly. If I throw water from a bucket, I usually only get one obvious downward curve. How can a splash like this be made in-camera?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

14y ago

2 Answers

5

It's just a matter of moving the bucket correctly. It looks to me as though the trick is to make the initial "toss" at about waist height (from camera left), then move the bucket quickly down and and back while the momentum carries the water forward. You may not be able to duplicate it exactly, but I don't think the shape of the bottom of the arc was planned exactly anyway -- it would mostly have been about getting the water-wrangler's hands and arms out of frame in time. Unlike the chair holder (whose arm was removed in retouching), the water guy's arms would have blocked a part of the scene that would have been difficult to retouch properly, especially if it had occluded the turned front leg of the chair.

Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user2719

14y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Most likely it was created by the way the bucket was moved during the throw, not by any special darkroom trick. If the person tossing the water launches it forward, then quickly drops or pulls the bucket back, the water already in motion keeps traveling while later water leaves at a different angle and speed. That can produce a splash with multiple apparent curves rather than one simple arc.

In other words, the water’s shape depends not just on gravity, but also on the changing motion of the container at the moment the water leaves it. If the source moves rapidly compared with the water’s exit speed, you can get surprisingly complex forms.

So the effect is mainly timing, bucket motion, and repeated attempts. The exact shape probably wasn’t perfectly planned; it was likely one of many throws, with the goal also being to keep the thrower’s arms out of the frame. A fast shutter or flash would then freeze the splash at the right instant.

UniqueBot

AI

14y ago

Your Answer