How should I set black, white, and midtone points with histogram adjustment when scanning film or prints?
Asked 6/4/2017
7 views
2 answers
0
I’m using an Epson V600 and trying to understand the scanner software’s Histogram/Levels adjustment. What do the black, white, and middle sliders do, what does the histogram’s x-axis represent, and why do the default black/white points sometimes sit inside the histogram rather than just outside it? In general, should I place the end points at the edges of the data, or intentionally clip some tones?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
1
Yes, your assumption is generally the way I handle levels. It will, of course, depend on the image you are scanning. If you're scanning an intentionally low-contrast image - perhaps a light colored object in fog - then you would not want to do it that way as you'd be introducing contrast that wasn't intended. But for typical content, you are correct.
Typically, the x-axis represents either the luminance or channel brightness of pixels, and the y-axis is the number of pixels in the image at that luminance. So the left-most arrow is the black point. Wherever you put that in the histogram, that luminance will be mapped to 0. Everything below it will be clipped to 0. The right-most arrow is white point. It gets mapped to 255 and everything above it gets clipped to 255. The middle arrow is gamma and affects the mid tones in the image.
I notice that the output black point is set to 18 rather than 0. I normally leave the output set to 0 and 255 unless there's a valid reason not to. (For some video formats 16-240 is preferred.)
Originally by user22895. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user22895
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In scanner histogram/levels controls, the x-axis is tone value or brightness (often luminance, or per-color-channel brightness if you’re viewing channels separately). The y-axis is how many pixels fall at each brightness.
The left slider sets the black point: that input value becomes pure black, and anything darker is clipped. The right slider sets the white point: that input value becomes pure white, and anything brighter is clipped. The middle slider adjusts midtones/gamma.
For many normal scans, moving black and white points in to the edges of the histogram is a reasonable starting point because it uses the available tonal range well. But it is not always correct. If the original scene is intentionally low contrast, stretching it to full black and white can make it look wrong.
Defaults may be inside the histogram because some images benefit from a little clipping to increase contrast, especially B&W scans. In color images, aggressive clipping can lose highlight/shadow detail and can shift color if channels clip unevenly.
Workflow matters too: if you’re making a finished JPEG, set the points for the look you want. If you’re scanning at high bit depth for later editing, it’s often better to avoid heavy clipping and preserve as much data as possible.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What does the histogram’s vertical axis mean in Lightroom or Adobe Camera Raw?
Why are Photoshop Levels controls called input levels and output levels?
How are Levels and Curves related in photo editing?
Why do many digital photos look better after adjusting levels or contrast?
Can software automatically adjust levels or exposure for a batch of photos?