How often should you create a new ColorChecker profile for different lighting?
Asked 3/5/2017
4 views
2 answers
0
I’m considering using a ColorChecker to improve color accuracy, mainly for available-light and outdoor photography rather than studio product work. My idea was to build a library of profiles for common lighting situations—such as noon daylight, sunset, window light, incandescent, fluorescent, and streetlights—and reuse them later instead of carrying the ColorChecker everywhere.
Is that a worthwhile approach? How much does color rendering really change with different light sources beyond white balance, and when is it actually useful to make a new ColorChecker profile?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
2
As often as you need. If you do not need it do not use it.
Instead of trying to make profiles for all, it is better to carry the checker if you need it.
Cases where you need it/ do not need it.
You make product shoots and you need the colors of the product be as accurate as possible. / You are making a still life. The image or light just looks good.
You are using different cameras, a wedding photography where you have 2 or 3 photographers using different cameras, or a video sequence where again, you need to have consistent colors during the movie. / You are taking casual photos.
It has no sense of making a color profile of "sodium vapor" lights for example, because you will never use that light for a color product shoot. In those cases you want a mood, not to change that yellow light to "white".
In most situations, there is a chance that making a white balance is enough.
If you want to play, go ahead.
Just some notes regarding your comments.
As Michael Clark commented. Color calibration is made after the shoot is made. It is a post process.
1) You take a sample shot of a white target, or your Macbeth color chart but as a reference.
2) Based on that information you make a profile of modifications that will be applied to subsequent images in Lightroom or Photoshop.
What does improve your dynamic range, or better said, optimizes your existing camera's dynamic range is proper exposure.
A light meter gives you a reading of the light and recommends the proper exposition.
But there is a chance your camera has a slight variation on the middle gray for some reason, or has more sensitivity in the brighter zone.
Some high end exposimeters help you make a dynamic range calculation on your camera. The explanation is out of range of this answer, but basically after this series of measures and comparations with your camera images, it saves some adjustments on the light meter itself and the next time you take a reading, gives you a value optimized for your camera.
There are several methods to do that and depends on the light meter, some are a series of bracketed shots and others are using a grayscale target.
And after your exposimeter has this information, next time you take a shot using this values, the shoot itself, therefore the raw data captured, will be with the maximum dynamic range your camera can provide.
Originally by user37321. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user37321
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A ColorChecker profile is most useful when you need critical color accuracy or consistency—such as product photography or matching multiple cameras. In that case, you should make a new profile whenever the lighting changes enough that accurate matching matters.
For general outdoor or available-light photography, building a big library of lighting-specific profiles is usually not very worthwhile. Different light sources can vary a lot, and a profile made under one fluorescent or streetlight may not translate well to another. If accuracy is important, it’s better to photograph the ColorChecker in the actual light you’re using.
Also, calibration is not just white balance, but it is not magic either: it improves rendering for the chart’s reference colors and helps standardize reproduction, yet it won’t perfectly solve every color under every spectrum.
So the practical rule is:
- critical color work: profile as needed when light changes
- casual, artistic, or mood-driven work: usually skip it
- if you want the natural look of sunset, tungsten, or sodium vapor, profiling to neutralize it may work against the image rather than help it
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do LED lights differ from conventional lights for photography?
Can you determine a lamp’s color temperature from a photo or EXIF data?
Why does my custom X-Rite ColorChecker profile look wrong on a Sony a7R IV?
Why does an X-Rite ColorChecker Passport profile made in sunlight produce wildly wrong colors?
How do CFL and incandescent bulbs differ for skin tones and softbox lighting?