How mechanical and electronic shutters work in digital cameras

Asked 11/23/2016

3 views

2 answers

0

When comparing digital cameras, I’m confused about how shutter mechanisms affect the actual exposure. Does a mechanical shutter in a digital camera work essentially the same way as in a film camera, so that a long shutter speed means the sensor is exposed continuously for that full time rather than the camera combining multiple frames?

I’m also trying to understand rolling vs global exposure. With a CMOS sensor, does using a mechanical shutter make the exposure effectively global, or can rolling-shutter effects still happen depending on shutter speed?

Finally, what does an electronic shutter do in practice? Is it controlling the amount of time each pixel collects charge before readout, and what are the practical trade-offs versus a mechanical shutter?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

4

Firstly, does a mechanical shutter in a digital camera work the same way as in a film-based camera?

Yes, it's exactly the same.

If I use a slow shutter speed, am I actually exposing the sensor for a prolonged period of time or is this more like capturing a video and then layering the frames on top of each other?

The former. Shutter speed determines the duration of the exposure of the sensor. Many digital cameras can record video, too, of course, and in that mode they capture a sequence of distinct frames, but I don't think that's what you're asking about.

Secondly, do mechanical shutters provide a global shutter for CMOS sensors or does one still get a rolling shutter effect? Again, what about very slow or very fast shutter speeds?

The mechanical shutters you find in most DSLRs will give a rolling shutter effect at high speed, because the shutter only exposes a small part of the sensor at once as the first and second curtains travel across it with only a small slit between them. At slower speeds there's a period where the entire sensor is exposed at the same time, after the first curtain finishes moving and before the second curtain starts, so the effect is more like a global shutter. The shutter operation doesn't change -- only the time between the movement of the two curtains does.

There are also other types of shutters, like leaf shutters. These are pretty uncommon, but not unheard of. And of course there are electronic shutters, which can also be divided into rolling and global categories, depending on how they're designed.

Originally by user4262. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user4262

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A mechanical shutter in a digital camera works essentially like one in a film camera: it controls how long light reaches the sensor. A long shutter speed is one continuous exposure, not the camera stacking video frames.

With focal-plane mechanical shutters, the first curtain opens and the second closes. At slower speeds the whole sensor is uncovered at once for a period of time; at very fast speeds a narrow slit travels across the sensor, so different parts are exposed at slightly different times. That means mechanical shutters are not always perfectly “global” at high speeds.

An electronic shutter generally works by starting and ending the sensor’s exposure electronically, then reading the image data out. In principle, exposure time is the time each pixel is allowed to collect charge. The main issue is readout: many CMOS sensors are read line-by-line, which can produce rolling-shutter distortion with fast subject or camera movement.

In practice, mechanical shutters can reduce some electronic-shutter artifacts and are often preferred with flash or very fast motion, while electronic shutters offer silent shooting and less shutter wear. The exact behavior depends on the camera and sensor design.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer