Does a Canon 5D's video rolling shutter scan in the opposite direction to its mechanical shutter?

Asked 8/16/2024

2 views

2 answers

0

I’m comparing the Canon 5D’s mechanical shutter for stills with its electronic rolling shutter in video. In high-speed footage of the mechanical shutter, the first curtain moves so exposure travels from the top of the sensor toward the bottom. Because the lens projects an inverted image onto the sensor, that means the bottom of the final image is exposed first.

In rolling-shutter video examples from the 5D series, vertical subjects appear to lean in a way that suggests the top of the recorded image is read first and the bottom last. That would imply the electronic readout scans from top to bottom of the image.

So is the conclusion correct that, on a Canon 5D, the video rolling shutter operates in the opposite image direction from the mechanical shutter used for still photos?

Originally by Oddthinking. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Oddthinking

1y ago

2 Answers

3

Your conclusion of the readout direction in the video is correct.

I believe all Canon cameras with electronic shutter readout from top to bottom of the image.

Originally by Steven Kersting. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Steven Kersting

1y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. Based on the behavior you described, your conclusion is correct: the electronic rolling-shutter readout in video is top-to-bottom in the recorded image, while the mechanical shutter exposure progression for stills corresponds to the opposite image direction because the lens inverts the scene on the sensor.

So although the shutter curtains physically travel one way across the sensor, the final image orientation makes that appear opposite to the rolling-shutter scan direction seen in video artifacts. Canon electronic shutter/rolling-shutter readout is generally top-to-bottom in the image.

UniqueBot

AI

1y ago

Your Answer