How does Photoshop display Lab (D50/2) values on a monitor profiled to D65?

Asked 6/5/2018

6 views

2 answers

0

If I open a Lab image in Photoshop, the file’s Lab values are based on the standard Lab reference white (D50/2). My monitor, however, is calibrated/profiled to a D65 white point. Since Photoshop uses color management when displaying images, does the image on screen still represent those Lab values as accurately as possible? Also, would calibrating the monitor closer to 5000K/D50 make the on-screen Lab colors more accurate?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

1

Assuming you properly calibrated and profiled the monitor to D65 with the computer's GPU set to output to a D65 monitor it should.

Photoshop doesn't really take your monitor profile into account. But it doesn't have to because Photoshop isn't what displays your image: Your GPU and monitor do that. Photoshop outputs the image to your GPU in much the same way it outputs images when you export them to a file. It includes instructions regarding the proper color space along with the numerical values for the image and then the GPU translates that to the correct color levels to send to the monitor.

I think my monitor calibration is OK, so I will assume my monitor is displaying D50/2 Lab values. If I calibrate it to a 5000K white point, will the display of the D50/2 Lab values be more accurate?

If you calibrate it to D50, which is a little bit greener on the Green←→Magenta axis than a blackbody radiator at 5000K, they will. But only if your ambient lighting is also compliant with D50!

Keep in mind that our perception of what is white changes with the environmental light. If you are in an environment with light centered on 5000K and you have your monitor set to D65, "pure" white will look slightly blue to your eyes. Only when the ambient lighting is also D65 will pure white on the monitor look white to your eyes. Conversely, if your monitor is set to D50 and your ambient lighting is at D65, "pure" white on your screen will have a red/orange/amber tint to your eyes.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—if your monitor is properly calibrated/profiled and the color management chain is working correctly, Photoshop should display the image as accurately as your monitor can manage, even if the monitor white point is D65 and Lab uses D50 as its reference white.

The important point is that color-managed display converts from the image color space to the monitor’s color space using the monitor profile. So the screen is not trying to “be Lab”; it is trying to reproduce the intended appearance of the Lab image on your specific display.

Setting the monitor to D50 does not automatically make Lab images more accurate. In practice, accuracy depends more on correct calibration/profiling and proper color management than on matching the monitor white point to Lab’s reference white. A D50-calibrated monitor may be preferable in some print-matching workflows, but it is not inherently more accurate for displaying Lab values on screen.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer