How does lens element separation affect image quality?

Asked 8/12/2013

2 views

2 answers

0

If a cemented lens group starts to separate with age, what kinds of image problems can it cause? I'm interested in the practical effects on photos, and whether mild edge separation differs from more serious separation.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

4

Do you actually have this lens or is it just a hypothetical?

The effect on the image would probably depend on how defocused the image is at the point that the sandwiched lenses meet or exactly how far the lens elements have shifted out of place. But if you permit me to make wild speculations, it could be one or more of:

  • Lower contrast, more "haze"

  • Increased flare or ghosting.

  • Change in corner softness or sharpness across the frame.

  • Change in ability to focus at the extremes, such as not focusing as close or not reaching infinity, or vice versa.

  • Imprint of what looks like blurry, dirty marks on the image caused by remnants of whatever of the "cement" remained between the lenses.

  • Or, it could have very little noticeable effect at all.

Originally by user3422. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user3422

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Lens separation can range from barely noticeable to severe, depending on how much of the group has separated and where it is.

Common effects include lower contrast, a hazy look, more flare or ghosting, and changes in sharpness—often toward the corners or unevenly across the frame. In more serious cases, separation or resulting misalignment can affect focusing, such as making close focus or infinity focus less reliable. If adhesive residue remains between elements, it may also cause blurry-looking marks or uneven image degradation.

Mild separation near the edge of an element may have only a slight effect, especially if it stays outside the most critical image-forming area. Full separation is usually much worse because the newly exposed internal surfaces are not coated, which increases reflections, and one or more elements may no longer be properly aligned.

If you suspect separation, inspect the lens against a bright light. Bubble-like patterns or discolored areas, often near the edge of an element, are common signs.

Occasionally, defects like this can produce a distinctive “character” some photographers use creatively, but in general lens separation is considered a fault that reduces optical performance.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer