How does a camera choose aperture and shutter speed in full auto mode?
Asked 11/17/2013
1 views
2 answers
0
In aperture priority or shutter priority, the camera only has to solve for one exposure variable after metering. But in full auto, both shutter speed and aperture can change, and those choices also affect depth of field and motion blur. Since the camera can't know whether I want a blurred or sharp background, how does it decide on the "best" combination in full auto mode?
Originally by user20359. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user20359
12y ago
2 Answers
10
How do automatic cameras know the right depth of field?
The short answer is, "They don't." They, or more specifically the designers who wrote the camera's firmware, guessed at it.
Different cameras use different solutions to arrive at the shutter speed and aperture when shooting in full auto, along with deciding other variables such as white balance, contrast, color saturation, sharpening, etc. Ultimately it is determined by the writers or the camera's firmware. Some systems are more sophisticated than others and may use context awareness to compare the scene with a database stored in the camera's memory. A predetermined list of settings attached to a profile in the database are then selected when the current conditions match one of those stored profiles.
Having said that, there are some common traits you see shared by many cameras. Most automatic profiles will try to avoid shutter speeds slower than one of several variations of the 1/focal length rule. They typically try to stay in the middle of the road in terms of aperture unless the target shutter speed pushes it further open. They generally try to use the lowest ISO possible and still meet the target shutter speed.
Auto Mode is usually written to cover as wide a set of possible scenarios and conditions as is possible. Cameras with several specialized auto profiles known as Scene Modes will use different priorities and goals for shutter speed, aperture, contrast, etc. depending on which scenario the user has selected. Again, different camera models have various different Scene Modes. For example, Sports Mode will place the emphasis on a fast shutter speed. Portrait Mode, on the other hand, will place the emphasis on a wide aperture and color balance that makes skin tones look their best. Each Scene Mode will apply a set of rules written by the camera's designers based on best practices for that particular type of scene.
Most inexpensive compact cameras that are often referred to as point-and-shoot cameras have such small sensor chips that the focal lengths used to get angles of view in the wide angle to normal to short telephoto range are so short that the depth of field is rather wide at almost any aperture the camera is capable of using, and the selection of aperture is based on what works with the target shutter speed and ISO values.
Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user15871
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
It doesn’t actually know your preferred depth of field. In full auto, the camera’s firmware makes an educated guess.
The camera meters the scene, then uses programmed exposure logic created by the manufacturer to choose a shutter speed/aperture combination. That program may be simple or more advanced depending on the camera. Some cameras also use scene recognition or context-aware profiles, comparing what the camera sees to stored scene types and then selecting settings the designers think will work well.
So in full auto, the camera is not deciding the “correct” depth of field for your artistic intent. It is choosing a compromise based on general rules, such as getting a usable exposure while trying to avoid blur, keep ISO reasonable, and match common scene types.
If you want direct control over depth of field, aperture priority or manual mode is the better choice.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do I choose a good aperture or shutter speed in Av/Tv mode when I don’t have a strong creative preference?
How do Canon P, A+ and Fv modes choose aperture, shutter speed and ISO?
How can I make a Canon EOS M6 use a faster shutter speed instead of staying at ISO 100 in auto exposure?
How can I get a faster shutter speed in a dim room without motion blur?
How can I use Auto ISO to favor a faster minimum shutter speed on a Canon DSLR?