How can I tell if the sky highlights are blown out, and what camera settings would improve this shot?

Asked 12/8/2016

3 views

2 answers

0

I’m learning photography and want to understand how to tell whether bright areas like a plain blue sky are actually blown out. In this photo, the sky has no clouds and looks very bright, but I’m not sure if that means the highlights are clipped.

Here are the EXIF details:

  • Focal length: 29 mm
  • Aperture: f/10
  • Shutter speed: 1/400 sec
  • ISO: 1000
  • Max aperture: f/4.1

How can I check for blown highlights on the camera or afterward, and what settings or exposure changes might have made the photo look better?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

1

Can you please tell me how to check whether the highlights are blownout when the sky is plain without clouds and dark blue??

Some cameras have a setting that'll show you any blown out details when you take the photo -- usually the affected areas flash on the camera's display. On my Canon the option is called "Highlight alert", selectable on one of the playback menus. So if you're looking for a general tool that you can use while taking photos, that's a good one to know about.

Just looking at the image histogram is another quick way to detect blown out details. The brightness histogram shows you the distribution of pixels in the image, with darkest pixels (black) on the far left and brightest pixels (white) on the right. If the histogram indicates a large number of pixels at the far right, that means blown out highlights. Most cameras can display such a histogram for you, so that's another tool to use while you're shooting. Photo editing software can usually show a histogram as well. Here's one from Apple's Photos app:

histogram

This one shows red, green, and blue components, and you can see that there are a significant number of pixels where all three components are at or near the maximum value.

Please point out the mistakes or any setting changes that might have made this snap a better one.

The first thing that occurs to me is the subject... you've got a photo of overgrown vegetation that's just not that interesting. Incorporating some object to act as a focal point in the image might help the composition. For example, you could get a friend to stand in the photo wearing a red or yellow jacket to add a splash of color. They don't even have to be recognizable -- they could stand a bit to the side and with their back to the camera, so it becomes a photo of a person looking out over the hills. Or if there's a statue or a tree around, you could use those as a point of interest.

As @fkraiem points out in a comment, it's likely that the photo you wanted to take had a lot more blue in the sky, and perhaps the blue sky and green plants were attractive at the time. If that's the case, reducing the exposure a bit might help keep the blue sky, although the leaves would likely be darker. Time of day can have a huge impact on this kind of photo: if you shoot in the early morning or late afternoon, the sky won't be as bright and you'll have an easier time getting a beautiful blue sky while still exposing the plants correctly.

Originally by user4262. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user4262

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

To check for blown highlights, use either:

  • the camera’s highlight alert (“blinkies”) in playback, or
  • the histogram.

On a brightness histogram, clipped highlights show up pushed hard against the far right edge. If the tones don’t reach that edge, the highlights usually are not blown.

Based on the answers, your image likely does not have truly blown highlights, but it does look overexposed. That’s different: overexposure means the image appears too bright overall, even if detail is still present.

A plain blue sky can look featureless without being clipped, especially if there are no clouds or strong tonal variations.

For a better result, the main setting change would have been using a lower ISO. ISO 1000 is unnecessarily high for a bright outdoor scene and can force a brighter exposure than needed. In similar light, use the lowest practical ISO, then set aperture and shutter speed accordingly.

Also remember: blown highlights are not always bad. In some scenes, small clipped bright areas are unavoidable or even acceptable. The key is whether important detail is lost where you want to keep it.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer