How can I print a dark object with bright details in the darkroom without losing either shadows or highlights?
Asked 6/25/2015
2 views
2 answers
0
In darkroom printing, how can I handle a scene where a large dark area contains many small bright details, such as white lettering on a dark table or bright clouds in a darker sky? If I dodge the dark area, I can bring out some shadow detail, but the bright details don’t print well. If I expose for the bright details, the dark area loses shadow detail. What darkroom techniques can help balance both?
Originally by user40720. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user40720
11y ago
2 Answers
1
(I didn't see the "darkroom" tag, so original answer was for digital, I've added non-digital to top)
Here I would either:
Lower contrast - either a lower contrast grade paper or choose a 1 or half contrast grade lower filter if using multi-contrast paper. That might give you the room you need to get both the dark table and white lettering.
Fancy dodging and burning - in my darkroom days I've made a print and then cut out where I wanted to burn (but smaller) and then held the cut-out print a little above another sheet of paper I'm exposing, taking care to avoiding sharp edges.
Both of the above - If you are using multi-contrast paper you can hide one area of the print (maybe with cutouts) and expose with one filter and then with a reverse cutout expose the rest of the paper with another filter. Crazy, but I've seen it used creatively (never tried it myself).
Negative masking - covered below.
In the digital world one would create a mask to protect part of the image and then use levels or curves on the unprotected part. The nice thing about this is that even with just Photoshop you can go back in later and change the mask or the toning (if you keep things in layers). A possible problem here is the white areas are out of focus, making the mask creation extra tedious.
But if you are using a relatively current version of Photoshop (not sure about the other applications) there is a quick global command you can try -- "Shadows/Highlights..." (in my Photoshop its located in Image->Adjustments). This gives a lot of the effects of masking and toning without the effort of creating a mask. The default values are a little heavy-handed, experiment. There are lots of tutorials on using the command creatively out there.
Originally by user2228. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user2228
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes. The main darkroom options are to reduce overall contrast and/or use selective exposure techniques.
A lower-contrast print may give you enough tonal range to hold both the dark area and the bright details. If you use multigrade paper, try a lower filter grade (for example, dropping by about half to one grade). On graded paper, use a lower contrast paper.
If that isn’t enough, use dodging and burning more selectively. One approach is to make a mask or cutout for the area you want to affect, keeping it slightly smaller than the target area and holding it a little above the paper during exposure to avoid hard edges.
With multigrade paper, you can also combine both ideas: expose one area with a lower contrast filter and the rest with a different filter, using cutouts to control which parts receive each exposure. This can help preserve shadow detail in the dark object while still keeping small bright details, like lettering, from disappearing.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I keep detail in both a bright sky and a darker landscape?
How can I bring out detail in both a dark subject and bright clouds from one RAW file in RawTherapee?
How can I post-process RAW aurora photos to improve color and impact?
How do you expose a high-contrast scene with deep blacks, bright whites, and a midtone subject?
How can I increase contrast without losing detail in shadows and midtones?