How can I recreate the lighting and setup of Edward Weston's Pepper No. 30?

Asked 4/7/2019

6 views

2 answers

0

I'm mainly an outdoor photographer and don't usually work with flash, reflectors, or other still-life lighting tools. After seeing Edward Weston's Pepper No. 30, I'd like to understand how a similar image might have been made. Was it likely shot with natural light or artificial light, and what role did the funnel/background play? I'm also interested in what matters beyond lighting when trying to achieve that kind of tonal quality and shape in a still life.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

7

I've re-thunk this since first posting ;)

Best guess is he just used natural light, not through his kitchen window, as I initially had assumed, because he states he didn't take it to the kitchen.

However, in the 1920s I would assume an artist would have an artist's loft*, with high, broad natural light... & a photographer would use one too, for similar reasons; that, combined with the reflected light inside the tin funnel the pepper was placed in & a 6-minute exposure, appear to have given him all he needed.

From Wikipedia - Pepper No 30

He first tried with plain muslin or a piece of white cardboard as the backdrop, but for these images he thought the contrast between the backdrop and the pepper was too stark. On August 3 he found a large tin funnel, and, placing it on its side, he set a pepper just inside the large open end. He wrote:

"It was a bright idea, a perfect relief for the pepper and adding reflecting light to important contours. I still had the pepper which caused me a week's work, I had decided I could go no further with it, yet something kept me from taking it to the kitchen, the end of all good peppers. I placed it in the funnel, focused with the Zeiss, and knowing just the viewpoint, recognizing a perfect light, made an exposure of six minutes, with but a few moments' preliminary work, the real preliminary was on in hours passed. I have a great negative, ‒ by far the best!"

By placing the pepper in the opening of the funnel, Weston was able to light it in a way that portrays the pepper in three dimensions, rather than as a flat image. It is this light that gives the image much of its extraordinary quality.

One thing about still life, which I do a lot of myself, is it never gets bored.
It leaves you to do all the thinking. It doesn't shuffle its feet or want a cup of tea, & blur your image if it has to hang a round a while. A flower stalk wilting slightly over a focus stack taking 5 minutes is about the worst you'll have to deal with.

*There is an entire row of these houses near where I used to work in London, all designed North-facing but with huge windows to admit lots of broad, indirect light. It's known colloquially as Artist's Row, in Chiswick, West London..

Pic, Credit:© Philip Ide Photography

enter image description here

I also found a newspaper article in the Daily Mail with pictures of the interior of one of them - can I have one please??

Originally by user57929. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user57929

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Based on the available information, Pepper No. 30 was most likely made with natural light rather than flash. Weston is said to have placed the pepper inside a large tin funnel after finding plain muslin or white card gave too much contrast. The funnel likely acted as both background and reflector, softening and shaping the light around the pepper. One answer also notes a long exposure of about 6 minutes, which strongly suggests continuous light, not flash.

To recreate the look, start with a single soft natural light source, place the subject inside or in front of a curved reflective surface, and adjust the angle until the highlights and shadows describe the form cleanly. The composition and exact pose of the pepper are a big part of the image.

Also, the final result was not only about lighting. Exposure, film choice, development, and darkroom printing were all crucial to the tonal richness. In digital terms, that means careful exposure and thoughtful post-processing. And, as one answer points out, experimentation matters: Weston made many pepper images before arriving at this one.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer