How can I measure tiny brightness variations in an almost saturated laser-beam image?
Asked 4/15/2013
2 views
2 answers
0
I need to measure extremely small intensity differences in a very bright image, such as a laser beam cross-section. The variations of interest are around 0.01% or smaller, and I only care about the top end of the signal range near maximum brightness. Is there a way to remap a normal camera's limited bit depth so that, for example, only the 99.99% to 100% intensity range uses the full output scale? Or is this fundamentally limited by sensor noise and quantization, meaning I need different hardware or technique?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
2
You can use curves to expand the dynamic range and make a very bright part of the image very dark and make a very very bright part still bright, but that isn't going to make more bits used on the very bright portion, just expose whatever detail is caught more clearly.
Even if you were somehow able to get the image processing to look only at the 99.99% to 100% intensities, noise is going to kill you. Unless the sensitivity and accuracy of the sensor is FAR FAR higher than the bit depth of the output normally allows, you are going to have all noise and no signal since the sensor likely can not detect such small variations reliably.
You actually want the opposite of high dynamic range, you want a very detailed but very VERY small dynamic range and the only real option for that is a purpose built sensor that is designed for detecting such minute differences accurately.
Originally by user11392. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11392
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Simply remapping tones or using curves will not create extra measurement precision. It can make tiny highlight differences more visible after capture, but it does not add real bit depth or recover detail the sensor did not record.
For measurements this small, the main limit is not just nominal 8-, 10-, or 14-bit output, but sensor noise and accuracy. If you try to isolate only the top 0.01% of the range, noise will likely overwhelm the signal unless the sensor itself is substantially more precise than its output format suggests.
So the practical answer is: a normal camera is usually the wrong tool for this. What you want is not high dynamic range, but very fine discrimination over a very narrow brightness range. That generally calls for purpose-built scientific/imaging hardware and controlled measurement methods rather than photographic tone mapping or gain tricks.
Reducing exposure and then boosting gain also won’t solve it in a meaningful way, because gain boosts noise along with signal.
In short: no simple camera setting or post-processing remap will turn an ordinary sensor into a reliable 0.01% measurement device near saturation; use a dedicated scientific sensor/system designed for that task.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I photograph scientific laser products, including a visible beam shot, in a lab?
How can I photograph a laser beam traveling through water?
How can I select pixels within a tonal range in GIMP?
How does shutter speed affect exposure if ISO and aperture stay the same?
Can a high-power laser damage a camera lens or its coatings?