How can I create safe, low-odor smoke or vapor for small product photos in a lab?

Asked 1/5/2019

5 views

2 answers

0

I’m photographing very small glass jars (about 3–5 cm tall) in a laboratory and want to add a subtle smoke/fog effect for atmosphere. Because this is in a lab, I can’t use strongly scented sources like cigarettes or incense. What are some safe, low-odor ways to produce a small amount of smoke or water vapor that would work for close-up studio photography?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

8

Most commercial photographers who use smoke a lot buy a commercially made "fog machine" that converts a fluid into dense vapor. The fluid is primarily made of water and glycerin. The machine simply heats the fluid in a semi enclosed space, producing the fog/smoke.

You can create such a machine yourself easily. You just need something that can hold the fluid above a heat source. An enclosed vessel with a hole in the top does better than a vessel with an fully open top, as it allows the vapor to collect above the fluid before escaping.

This DIY YouTube video shows how to cut apart an aluminum soft drink can to make a simple fog machine heated by a candle placed underneath it. Basically, the can is cut in half. The lower part is inverted with the concave "dimple" on the bottom holding the fluid and most of the side is cut away to allow a small candle to have a source of fresh air. The top half of the can is then placed on top of the inverted bottom half with the small hole in the top open to allow the fog to escape.

enter image description here

This DIY instruction uses a mini pie tin with the inverted top cut off a two-liter soda bottle taped to the top of the pie tin, which is suspended above a large candle. This YouTube video makes a similar device.

enter image description here

The trick with any of these DIY devices is to only use a small bit of fluid, say a teaspoon to a tablespoon (5-15 ml), at a time. You'll be surprised at just how much "fog" will be made using such a small amount of glycerin and water!

Instead of buying commercially made "fog juice", you can make your own with distilled water and glycerin. Your water must be pure and free of chemicals such as those often added to tap water, like chlorine, fluoride, and various softening agents. Vegetable glycerin will work if no chemical grade glycerin is available. I've seen ratios of anywhere from three parts water to one part glycerin (25% glycerin) to a glycerin:water ratio of 7:3 (70% glycerin). Most sources go with about 25-35% glycerin content.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—use a vapor/fog source rather than burning material. The most practical options mentioned were:

  • a fog machine using water/glycerin-based fog fluid
  • dry ice in water
  • an e-cigarette/vape using high-VG liquid with no aroma or nicotine

For a lab, the cleanest low-odor choices are a small fog machine or vapor from plain vegetable glycerin-based fluid. These create visible suspended vapor without the smell of incense or cigarettes.

Dry ice in water also works, but it behaves more like low-lying fog and may be less controllable for tiny tabletop scenes. Handle dry ice with gloves and use normal ventilation.

An e-cigarette can be a cheap way to generate a small amount of visible vapor quickly, especially with high-VG, unflavored, nicotine-free liquid.

Whichever method you use, keep the amount small, avoid open flames if lab rules prohibit them, and check lab safety policies first. For product shots this size, a subtle controlled puff of vapor is usually more convincing than a large cloud.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer