How can I photograph smooth water without an ND filter?

Asked 4/9/2016

2 views

2 answers

0

I want to shoot rivers or lakes with a long exposure to blur the water, but I don't own a neutral density (ND/grey) filter. Even at low ISO and a small aperture, my photos are overexposed in daylight. Are there any practical ways to get this effect without an ND filter, and how should I think about the shutter time needed for smooth-looking water?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

20

You can merge multiple short exposure photos into a single long exposure image. There are a lot of tutorials on the net, for example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nAuQWfS3pLg

Basically, he opens the sequence of photos in photoshop as layers in a single picture, then "auto-align layers", "convert to smart object" and "stack mode" - "mean".

Image alignment (the most time consuming task) can be avoided if the camera is perfectly stable between shots. If your photos are already aligned, basic stacking can be performed very quickly, even without sophisticated tools, for example this is how the free and open source ImageMagick does that:

convert  photo1.jpg photo2.jpg photo3.jpg -evaluate-sequence mean  result.jpg

Originally by user32811. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user32811

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Without an ND filter, your options are limited. First, use the least light possible: set ISO to minimum and stop the lens down as far as practical. You can also shoot when light levels are lower, such as near sunset or after the sun drops lower in the sky, which allows longer shutter speeds.

Another workaround is to simulate a long exposure by taking many shorter exposures and averaging them in software. Stacking the images with a mean/average blend can create a smoother water look similar to a single long exposure, as long as the camera stays perfectly still.

As for the “needed” shutter time: there isn’t one fixed value. The right time depends on how fast the water is moving and how smooth you want it to look. Faster water needs less time; calmer water usually needs more. Without an ND filter in bright daylight, you may simply not be able to reach the necessary shutter speed in one shot.

So in practice: lower ISO, use a small aperture, shoot in dimmer light, or stack multiple frames. If you want the effect reliably in daylight, an ND filter is the proper tool.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer