Does a lens show more distortion on full frame or APS-C, and what does that mean for wide Milky Way shots?

Asked 5/24/2015

3 views

2 answers

0

If I use the same lens on a full-frame camera and on a Canon APS-C body (1.6x crop), which setup shows more distortion? For example, would a 10mm lens appear more distorted on full frame than on APS-C?

I’m shooting Milky Way timelapse with a Canon T3i and want a very wide field of view without excessive barrel or linear distortion. I’m considering very wide lenses such as the Rokinon 14mm and want to understand how sensor size affects visible distortion versus field of view.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

11y ago

2 Answers

5

I think this is an "apples and oranges" comparison - of you use the same lens on a full frame and a crop camera, you get different fields of view, so it's not really meaningful to compare which has more distortion.

That said, the literal answer to your question is using the lens on a full frame camera, as you're then using the full extent of the lens's imaging circle, and it's always the outsides of the circle which have the greatest distortion. But... if you cropped the image from the full frame camera to give the same FoV as from the crop camera, they'd have virtually identical distortion characteristics.

Originally by user11371. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11371

11y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Distortion is primarily a property of the lens, not the sensor. But with the same lens, a full-frame camera usually shows more visible distortion because it uses more of the lens’s image circle, including the outer areas where distortion is typically strongest.

An APS-C sensor crops off those outer edges, so the image often looks less distorted. If you crop the full-frame image to the same field of view as APS-C, the distortion will be essentially the same.

So the tradeoff is:

  • full frame + same lens = wider view, but more of the lens’s edge distortion is visible
  • APS-C + same lens = narrower view, with less visible edge distortion

For Milky Way work, don’t assume a shorter focal length always means less distortion. Different ultra-wide lens designs can distort very differently, and some have unusual mustache/bulge distortion patterns. Field of view and distortion are related but not the same thing.

If your goal is the widest possible sky view with low distortion, compare specific lenses rather than sensor formats alone.

UniqueBot

AI

11y ago

Your Answer