Do white balance, color tone, and scene modes change the actual capture or only the camera’s processing?
Asked 1/11/2012
3 views
2 answers
0
When you change settings like white balance, color tone/picture style, and scene modes, do they alter how the image sensor records the photo, or are they mainly processing choices applied after capture? I’m especially wondering which of these settings affect the actual exposure/capture versus the JPEG rendering.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
6
The question What's "real" and what's "virtual" on a (digital) camera? has several answers which list the things which are "real" — that is, the things which affect the capture of the RAW image. To crib from the top answers, these things are:
- ISO
- Aperture
- Shutter Speed
- Focus
with some more technical things like image stabilization and mirror lockup as well.
The answers there don't really cover what's "not real", except by elimination, so let me go over your specifics.
White balance and color tones do not affect these "real" things directly — they're applied to the RAW image in in-camera (or out of camera) post processing. However, it's not quite straightforward, since the selected options can affect the metering — a very blue-shifted white balance might cause a different interpretation of what the exposure should be than a very yellow-shifted one. That, in turn, may make the camera's automatic modes choose slightly different settings. But that's a bit esoteric: the straight answer is white balance and color tones are "after effects".
But "scene modes" are somewhat different, since they apply a whole grab-bag of different settings. Some of these, like a fast shutter speed for a sports mode, will almost certainly affect the real image. Others, like portrait modes, may simply chose post-processing options more suited for delicate-appearing skin.
Your last two, contrast and sharpness, are also an "it depends". These things are strongly influenced by the lens you use, your aperture selected, and correct focus. So in that sense, they are real and unalterable. But, local and global contrast can also be boosted in post-production, and usually is — in fact, usually very much so in the default JPEG output from most cameras. Without that, the out-of-camera images would look much more dull and flat than we are accustomed to. A good camera — or RAW processing software — will give you a lot of individual control over these parameters in the post-processing sense.
Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1943
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In general, white balance and color tone/picture style do not change what the sensor records in a RAW file. They are mainly instructions for how the camera processes and renders the image, especially for JPEGs. If you shoot RAW, these settings are usually stored as metadata and can be changed later.
Scene modes are different: they often change capture settings such as shutter speed, aperture, ISO, autofocus behavior, flash use, and metering, and may also apply JPEG processing choices like saturation, contrast, and sharpening. So scene modes can affect both the capture and the final rendered image.
A useful rule of thumb: the settings that directly affect capture are exposure and focus related—aperture, shutter speed, ISO, and focus (plus some technical functions like stabilization). White balance and color styles are mostly rendering choices, not sensor-capture changes.
One caveat: even settings that are mostly “processing” can sometimes indirectly influence metering or other automatic decisions, depending on the camera.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do Canon Picture Styles affect white balance when shooting RAW?
On a Canon EOS 700D, is Scene mode Portrait/Landscape the same as using the matching Picture Style in P/Av/Tv/M?
Why can white balance be changed easily on RAW files but not as accurately on JPEGs?
In photography, do "skin color" and "skin tone" mean different things?
Do Canon Picture Styles affect RAW files, and should I choose one when shooting RAW?