Do rear drop-in filters need to stay installed in telephoto lenses that use them?

Asked 7/23/2017

6 views

2 answers

0

Some telephoto lenses, including certain Nikon super-telephotos, have a built-in rear drop-in filter holder. Is a filter meant to remain installed for the lens to perform to specification, or can the lens be used normally with the holder empty? Optically, does removing that rear filter change focus or image quality enough to matter?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

1

I think I have the answer from these 2 user manuals extracts, though from an optical point of view I don't know for sure how the image suffers from the absence of the inner filter.

From the user manual of the nikon AF-S_VR_200-400mm: enter image description here

From the user manual of the nikkor 400mm f/2.8 IF ED: enter image description here

While the above (nikkor 400mm) only says "always use a filter" without specifying whether it's a front or rear filter, the remaining of the recommendation points toward the inner (rear) filter, which is clearly mentioned for the 200-400mm. If someone wants to constructively elaborate by explaining what happens to the image without the filter, welcome!

Originally by user61932. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user61932

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Usually yes: if the lens was designed with a rear drop-in filter slot, the manufacturer often expects a clear or other filter to be installed. Manuals for some Nikon telephotos explicitly say to always use a filter.

Optically, a flat parallel filter does affect the light path, even though it has no optical power like a lens element. Its presence slightly shifts the focus position (roughly on the order of about one-third of the filter thickness, depending on material). In some lenses, refocusing may compensate; in others, especially where internal focusing groups are involved, removing it could move the lens away from its intended design condition.

A good filter is an optical flat, so it should not significantly add aberrations by itself, but adding or removing it can alter spacing enough to matter slightly. Filters also add two reflective surfaces, which can increase flare and reduce contrast, though coatings minimize this.

So the practical answer is: if the lens manual says to keep a rear filter installed, use one—typically a clear/neutral drop-in filter—if you want the lens to match the maker’s intended optical performance.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer