Do I need a dedicated macro ring flash if I already have an off-camera Speedlite?
Asked 5/11/2011
2 views
2 answers
0
I shoot macro mostly on a tripod without flash, but I also have a Canon Speedlite that I can trigger off-camera from my camera body. I'm considering a dedicated macro ring flash/twin flash for close-up work and want to know when it offers a real advantage over a normal external flash.
Is a macro ring flash mainly useful when:
- shooting handheld or using flash heavily for macro, or
- working at very short subject distances where a regular flash may be hard to position?
For tripod-based macro of stationary subjects, is my existing off-camera Speedlite usually enough, especially with diffusion and careful positioning?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
15y ago
2 Answers
6
In my opinion flash tends to be better than a tripod for macro as you get more control, faster shutter speeds and you can close the aperture really far down. That's not to say you can't get good results with available light.
You can also get good results without a dedicated macro ringlight, if you have a off camera cord. This will let you get your 430EX close to the subject and allow you to find the optimum lighting angle. Diffusing the light will fill in shadows like a ringflash, though shadows aren't usually a problem as even a bare flash is a large (i.e. soft) lightsource compared to a macro subject.
It's definitely worth experimenting to see what you can do with your current gear before investing in a ring light or adaptor.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
15y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A dedicated macro ring/twin flash is helpful, but not essential for many macro shots.
If you already have an off-camera Speedlite, you can often get very good macro results by placing it close to the subject and diffusing it. In macro, even a normal flash can act like a relatively large, soft light source, so harsh shadows are often less of a problem than expected. It’s worth experimenting with your current flash first.
Where a ring or twin macro flash really helps is at very short working distances. Because it mounts around the lens, it can illuminate subjects that are hard to light from the side or above with a regular flash. That makes it especially useful for insects, tiny objects, and other close subjects where lens-to-subject distance is tight.
A tripod is still useful for stationary subjects, but flash often gives more control: faster shutter speeds, more depth of field from stopping down, and less dependence on ambient light. For moving subjects, flash is often more useful than a tripod.
So: for stationary subjects on a tripod, your current off-camera Speedlite is usually enough. Consider a macro ring/twin flash mainly if your subjects are extremely close, hard to light, or you want a more convenient dedicated macro setup.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI15y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What flash setup works best for general macro photography, especially insects and still subjects?
Cheap DIY lighting options for macro photography at home
Can I combine an external flash with a ring flash for macro photography?
Do you need a ring flash for macro photography?
What are the advantages of using a ring flash for portrait photography?