Do extension tubes reduce image quality, and how do they work?
Asked 10/1/2013
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m considering using extension tubes for close-up or macro photography. How do extension tubes actually work, and can a good-quality extension tube reduce image quality? I’m especially wondering whether any loss comes from the tube itself or from other factors like lens behavior, alignment, or autofocus/aperture compatibility.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
12
Extension tubes work by moving a lens further from the film or sensor.
The closer an object is to the lens, the further back the focussed image will appear, hence extension tubes allow you to focus on objects closer to the lens than would be possible otherwise. They are commonly used a cheap way to improve the macro abilities of a lens.
There are a few ways image quality could be compromised
Floating elements. Some lenses include a "floating" element (just a lens that moves independently of the focussing group) in order to reduce aberrations when focussing close up. If you set the lens focus to a distant setting and then use extension tubes to obtain close focus then you wont be getting the benefit of the floating element and image quality can suffer.
Misalignment of the lens. A certain amount of misalignment is inevitable though most cases it will not have a noticeable impact on image quality. In extreme cases this could manifest itself in a tilt in the plane of focus, e.g. the right side of the image might be in focus but the left side out of focus.
Light leakage or flare (unlikely unless the tube is very badly made, though possible for a DIY effort).
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Extension tubes work by moving the lens farther from the sensor/film plane. This lets the lens focus much closer than normal, which is why tubes are often used for macro work.
A true extension tube contains no glass, so by itself it does not directly degrade image quality the way an optical accessory can. However, image quality can still suffer indirectly:
- poor build quality can cause misalignment, reflections, or light leaks
- some tubes lack electronic contacts, so autofocus may not work and aperture control may be limited on lenses without an aperture ring
- many lenses are not optimized for close focus this way; if a lens uses floating elements, tubes may bypass some of that close-focus correction
- close-up use magnifies lens flaws, making aberrations more noticeable
In practice, a well-made extension tube usually won’t add optical degradation on its own, but the final result depends a lot on the lens and the tube’s mechanical/electronic quality. For macro shooting, manual focus is commonly used anyway because depth of field is extremely shallow.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can I combine extension tubes and a close-up filter on a macro-capable lens?
macro lens vs extension tubes for close-up photography on a nikon d7200
Is a telephoto lens better than an 18-55mm kit lens for macro with extension tubes?
Do extension tubes or Raynox close-up lenses reduce image quality compared with a dedicated macro lens?
Can the Nikon D3200 with 18-105mm VR shoot insects and close-up macro photos?