Can you tell from photos whether a minaret is actually tilted or just distorted by perspective?
Asked 11/7/2019
3 views
2 answers
0
I have a photo of a minaret at Al-Masjid an-Nabawi that appears to lean. I can’t visit the site or take new test shots, so I’m limited to images already available online. From one photo, or from several photos, is it possible to determine with reasonable confidence whether the minaret is truly tilted or whether the apparent lean is just caused by camera angle, perspective, or lens distortion? What reference points would be needed to judge this reliably?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
6y ago
2 Answers
3
The answer is maybe. It depends on whether the photos have required reference points to make the determination. If the required points exist on the photograph, yes.
Verticality (plumb) is established as the line between the zenith (point overhead) and the nadir (centre of the planet). Any eccentricity from that is considered "tilted."
The horizon is perpendicular to this imaginary line which can be established as the line joining the vanishing points (where receding parallel lines viewed in perspective appear to converge.) Any eccentricity from a line perpendicular to the horizon (level) is considered "tilted."
Any photograph used to define perpendicularity must have at least one dependable reference line (plumb and/or level) to use for linear construction and comparison.
You will need at least two of these photographic images taken from different orthogonal positions (90° with respect to the tower) to answer your question definitively. Additionally, it is handy for the camera axis to be "true." That is to be dead level with the subject centred horizontally and vertically in the viewfinder since, in effect, you are using the camera as a surveying (disambiguation) instrument.
Quite apart from the photographic evidence that may or may not exist, I'd tend to believe the popular claim. Any equipped and motivated land surveyor with a couple of hours off could provide the answer to a fraction of a degree.
Originally by user21789. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user21789
6y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A single photo usually cannot prove it. An object may appear to lean because of camera roll, perspective, or lens distortion, and one image also cannot reveal tilt toward or away from the camera.
You can make a reasonable assessment if the photo includes reliable reference lines. In architectural scenes, level lines and plumb lines let you infer a horizon/vertical reference from perspective. After correcting lens distortion and camera tilt/roll, you can compare the tower to lines that should be vertical or perpendicular to known level features. If those references are dependable, you may estimate whether the structure is out of plumb.
Based on the community answers, the apparent lean in the example image is likely due to distortion and camera angle rather than an actually bent minaret. But from one image alone, that is not a proof.
If you can find multiple photos from different viewpoints, especially with known straight architectural references, your confidence improves. A true structural tilt should remain consistent across corrected images from different positions.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI6y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why does leveling the horizon make the lighthouse lean, and how can I fix it?
Can you make a wide-angle interior photo look like it was shot with a narrower field of view in post?
What software can straighten a tilted photo or correct perspective distortion?
Why do faces near the edges look stretched or skewed in smartphone photos?
Can a bird's head look distorted in flight because of angle, or is it likely photo editing?