Can you add a quick-release system separately to a ball head, and should you choose RC2 or Arca-Swiss?

Asked 3/19/2016

10 views

2 answers

0

I'm considering a Manfrotto 498 ball head. The older 498RC2 version with the built-in RC2 quick-release appears to be discontinued, while the plain 498 without a quick-release is still sold.

Is it a good idea to buy the ball head first and add a separate quick-release adapter later? More generally, are quick-release systems interchangeable with ball heads?

I'm also trying to understand plate types. I often see Arca-Swiss recommended. Does Manfrotto make an Arca-Swiss-compatible plate/adapter, and are these plates usually generic or camera-specific? I use a Nikon D5300.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

5

Almost all tripods have a 3/8 inch screw used to attach the tripod to a head.
Almost all heads have a 3/8 inch female connector used to attach the head to the 3/8" screw on the top of the tripod.

What is on the top of the head to which the camera is attached can vary a little more, but the end result is almost always a 1/4-20" screw that attaches to the camera or lens foot.

Some heads, such as the Manfrotto 498, have a fixed flat platform with a 1/4-20" screw. enter image description here
This can be attached directly to the camera (by spinning either the camera onto the tripod and attached head or by spinning the tripod and attached head onto the camera). To avoid all of that spinning as well as to facilitate faster swapping of one camera for another, quick detach systems can be used.

Quick release systems employ two components: the receiver/connector and the plate. When detached the plate can be attached to a camera or lens foot. To attach the camera to the tripod the plated is placed into the receiver and locked to it. The receiver can either be included integrally as part of a head or be an adapter that attaches to the top of a fixed head via the 1/4-20" screw that protrudes from the fixed head.

Here is a picture of a Manfrotto 323 RC2 adapter and a 200PL QR plate. The 200PL, on the left, fits into the 323 and can be locked to it. The 1/4-20" screw protruding out of the top of the 200PL plate is what screws into the bottom of your camera or lens foot. enter image description here
The same 200PL QR plate pictured above can also be attached directly to a head with an integrated RC2 receiver, such as the 498RC2 pictured below without a 200PL plate attached. enter image description here

Most heads that have an integrated quick release receiver/connector, such as the 498RC2, also include at least one QR plate (as pictured at B&H, amazon, and other online sellers with the 200PL plate attached to the integrated RC2 receiver of the 498RC2). enter image description here
Additional plates can usually be ordered separately. This is certainly the case with the Manfrotto RC2 system as additional 200PL plates are available for purchase individually. Most quick release adapters, such as the 323 RC2 Rapid Connector, also include a compatible QR plate. And of course since the plate is the same for each system (such as the RC2 system) regardless of whether the receiver is built in to the head or an add on adapter, we've already established it is available as an individual purchase.

My question is, is it a good idea to purchase a quick-release system separately from the ball-head?

It's not necessarily a bad idea, but why would you want to? If you know you wish to use quick release plates with a head and the head is offered in the QR format you desire, it seems simpler and cheaper to purchase the version of the head with the QD plate built in. You'll also save a little bit in terms of stack height and total weight.

On the other hand, if you later decide to change which quick release connector you use, having the ability to convert all of your existing heads to the new connector would be an advantage.

Manfrotto offers tripod heads with several quick release systems. Among them are the following:

  • The 200PL (also 200PL-14) QR plate fits the RC2 or Q2 connector.
  • The 410PL QR plate fits the RC4 connector
  • The 501PL QR plate fits the Q5 connector
  • The 030-14 and 130-14 QR plates fit the QR0 connector
  • The MSQ6PL plate fits the Q6 connector and is also compatible with Arca style systems from other manufacturers.

Not all Manfrotto heads are offered in all connectors. Some connectors are more compact and suitable for lighter loads while others are more robust and suitable for larger, heavier equipment. The RC2 and RC4 connectors have probably been the most popular among the ones listed above. Manfrotto has recently replaced a lot of their conventional ball heads with more expensive magnesium alloy heads and updated the RC2 connector and renamed it the Q2 connector. The receiver side is slightly different, but all variations of the 200PL plate will fit both systems.

The reason Manfrotto is discontinuing many of their heads such as the 498 is that they are introducing an updated line that has fresher, more modernistic styling and are made of magnesium. They are also quite a bit more expensive than the older aluminum alloy heads.

As Arca type connectors have become more popular among enthusiasts as well as pros, Manfrotto created the Q6 connector that uses an Arca compatible plate with a receiver that can be top loaded and has a spring loaded retaining feature that prevents the camera and lens from falling off the base before the dovetail is tightened down.

Here is the Manfrotto MHXPRO-BHQ6 with integrated Q6 receiver and the included MSQ6PL attached. The MSQ6PL is an Arca type plate. enter image description here
Here is the Manfrotto MHXPRO-BHQ2 with integrated Q2 receiver and the included 200PL plate attached.The 200PL plate is not an Arca type plate.
enter image description here

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. In many cases you can buy a ball head and add a separate quick-release adapter, as long as the mounting threads match.

Generally, tripods and heads use a 3/8" connection between tripod and head, and the camera side usually ends with a 1/4-20 screw. A head with a fixed top platform can often be converted to quick release by adding a plate adapter.

So buying the non-RC2 Manfrotto 498 and adding a QR adapter later is a reasonable approach. Just be sure you buy the correct adapter/plate system.

Manfrotto has made its own QR systems such as RC2 and RC4, and also an Arca-Swiss-style option (mentioned in the answers as the Q6). Arca-Swiss-style plates are widely recommended because they are a common standard across many brands.

Plates can be generic, but some are camera-specific or shaped for a better fit. For a Nikon D5300, a generic 1/4-20 plate will usually work unless you specifically want a body-matched plate.

In short: yes, separate QR systems are normal, and choosing a common system like Arca-Swiss can make future compatibility easier.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer