Can large white balance corrections in RAW processing increase visible noise?

Asked 5/10/2016

5 views

2 answers

0

If a photo is shot under lighting with a very different color temperature than the camera's white balance setting—for example, a fluorescent-lit subject shot with Cloudy WB—and then corrected heavily in post, can that make noise more visible? I understand that white balance changes on a RAW file are non-destructive, but since white balance works by boosting some color channels more than others, does an extreme WB correction effectively amplify noise in those channels, even though the RAW data itself is unchanged?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

5

Just because using different WB settings to demosaic the raw data is non-destructive to the raw data doesn't mean one WB setting will be more or less noisy than another. It's not so much that you will get equal quality regardless of how you choose to interpret the raw data, but rather that regardless of whatever interpretation you choose to use for the raw data, that interpretation does not change the raw data contained in the file - it only changes the way an image created from that data looks.

Beyond that, a raw file has no white balance. The raw data is a set of monochrome luminance values. When the raw data is demosaiced a WB profile is applied to the raw data, but there is no WB information contained in the actual raw data that was read out from the sensor. Whatever WB was selected in the camera at the time the photo was taken has absolutely no effect on the readout from the sensor data, it is only used to apply a WB to the raw data to produce the thumbnail/preview jpeg image attached to the raw file. It is also included in the file's metadata, but the application you use to open the raw file with may or may not apply the in camera WB setting. Many raw converters ignore the in-camera WB setting and either apply their own default value, apply a value included in a preset created by the user, or apply their own version of Auto WB.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—while RAW white balance is non-destructive to the file itself, a large WB correction can make noise more visible in the rendered image.

A RAW file does not contain a baked-in white balance; it stores sensor data plus metadata/instructions. Changing WB later does not alter the RAW data. However, white balance is applied during conversion by scaling color channels. If one channel must be boosted strongly to neutralize unusual light, its noise gets boosted too, so the final image can look noisier.

So both ideas are true:

  • WB changes to RAW are non-destructive.
  • Extreme WB corrections can still increase visible noise in the output image.

This is most noticeable under spectrally odd or very warm/cool light, where one or more channels are weak and need heavy amplification. Mild WB adjustments usually have little practical impact; extreme ones can.

In your snowflake example, pushing WB strongly cooler could make channel noise a bit more apparent, but the RAW file itself is unchanged. The issue is the interpretation/rendering of the data, not damage to the original capture.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer