Can image stabilization blur a shot if you take the photo before it has settled?
Asked 4/5/2012
5 views
2 answers
0
My Pentax camera uses sensor-shift stabilization (Shake Reduction), which starts on a half-press of the shutter and can take up to about a second to settle. If I shoot before it is ready, the image metadata shows stabilization as “On but Disabled.”
Can taking the shot before stabilization has settled actually make blur worse than turning stabilization off entirely? In other words, can the moving sensor or lens elements introduce blur, ghosting, or double images before the system is locked in?
I’m mainly asking about Pentax sensor-shift stabilization, but I’d also like to know whether the same issue applies to other stabilization systems, including in-body and lens-based IS.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
14y ago
2 Answers
7
Yes, an unsettled IS system will indeed cause blurring, ghosting, double-imaging, etc. I don't know if Pentax has in-camera IS or lens IS, and the characteristic blur from the Pentax may differ from what I get with my Canon IS lenses. I am also not sure exactly how long it might take a Pentax IS to "settle", however on my worst Canon IS lens, it takes less than a second. I know that sometimes a fraction of a second does matter, however as a general rule when using stabilized gear the rule of thumb is to shoot early and shoot often. You might notice sports photographers with the great white lenses usually shoot a couple seconds before any anticipated action actually occurs, partially to allow for IS settling.
I've learned a trick recently myself that helps with IS settling. I've started using back-button focus, wherein I've decoupled AF activate from my shutter button and configured a button near my right hand thumb as the button to activate AF. I normally use AI servo, but the same button works with single-shot AF as well. On a Canon, activating any one of AF, Metering, FEL, or shutter all initiate IS. By having independent control over AF, I also have independent control over IS, and I can usually keep IS activated if I anticipate the need to shoot, so by the time I actually do activate the shutter everything has already settled. I'm not sure if the Pentax supports reconfiguration of button functions, but if it does, you might try to separate AF control from shutter control, and give yourself a bit finer grained control over it all.
Originally by user124. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user124
14y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — if you shoot before the stabilization system has settled, it can make blur worse than having stabilization off.
From user experience with both Pentax sensor-shift SR and Canon lens-based IS, an unsettled system may produce extra blur, ghosting, or double-imaging because the sensor or lens group is still moving while trying to compensate. Pentax users report shots taken before the ready indicator appears can be blurrier than usual.
That said, the effect is not always worse in every shot, and the amount varies by system, lens, focal length, and timing. Some systems settle in less than a second. Pentax bodies provide a viewfinder indication when SR is stabilized; waiting for that is the safest approach when shutter speed is marginal.
In practice: if you need stabilization, half-press a little early and let it settle before shooting. If you must shoot instantly, disabling stabilization may be preferable to risking blur from a not-yet-stable system. This applies to both in-body and lens-based stabilization systems.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI14y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Will pressing the shutter on a tripod-mounted Lumia 1020 cause shake, and how can I avoid it?
Can I use non-stabilized lenses on a Pentax K-30, and how does in-body stabilization compare?
Can dust or humidity interfere with a camera's sensor-shift image stabilization?
What’s the difference between in-lens and in-body image stabilization, and which is better?
How does image stabilization compare with raising ISO for handheld low-light photos?