Can I use a 35mm slide copier on a Nikon D5100 APS-C camera, and what lens should I use?

Asked 7/15/2013

1 views

2 answers

0

I want to digitize a large number of 35mm slides and negatives using a slide copier, but my Nikon D5100 has an APS-C crop sensor. If I reduce the magnification to fit the full slide onto the sensor, will that affect anything besides resolution? For example, could it introduce distortion or other image quality issues? Also, what type of lens is best for this setup?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

2

There are a few different types of slide duplicator designs:

  • Some attach to the filter threads of a lens. This type of slide duplicator is easiest to use on crop-sensor bodies. Image quality depends mainly on the quality of the lens. Color quality depends on the light source.

    The duplicator is basically a slide attachment and a tube with a diopter filter inside. The macro filter may introduce some barrel distortion, which can be corrected in software. Any loss in image sharpness won't be significant as long as you are able to visualize and focus on the film grain.

    slide copier

    Use a zoom lens to find the appropriate focal length, then switch to a sharper prime, if you have one available. Use the minimum ISO available on your camera, and stop down to the sharpest aperture of your lens (usually F5.6 to F8). You don't have to worry too much about long exposure times since the attachment is motionless relative to the sensor. If your camera or lens has image stabilization, turn it off.

  • Some attach directly to the camera. All necessary optics are built into the duplicator. Some allow zooming from 1x to 2.5x. You can zoom in on sub-miniature formats, but you won't be able to zoom out to capture entire 35mm frames on crop-sensor bodies. You can capture and stitch multiple sections of the film.

  • Some are intended for use with bellows. Lens selection and bellows operation may require some trial and error. As the bellows is used to move the lens away from the sensor, sharpness is decreased and a "glow" may appear.

    bellows attachment

    You can use the thin lens formula to figure out approximate distances and focal lengths you'll need for a given reproduction ratio (magnification, m = v/u).

    1/u + 1/v = 1/f

    u = subject distance
    v = image distance
    f = focal length

    For 1:n, u = (n+1)f, v = (n+1)f/n. So for a 50mm lens with a reproduction ratio of 1:1.5, u = 83mm and v = 125mm.

Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user75526

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes — a slide copier can work fine on an APS-C camera like the Nikon D5100. The crop sensor itself does not cause extra distortion or otherwise change the appearance of the slide, as long as you use an appropriate lens and magnification. You simply need less magnification to fill the smaller sensor, which usually means using a shorter focal length than you would on full frame.

Possible image quality issues come more from the duplicator design and lens choice than from the sensor size. Filter-thread slide copiers often include a close-up/diopter element, and that accessory may introduce some barrel distortion, though it can usually be corrected in software. Sharpness should be good if you can focus clearly enough to see the film grain.

A zoom lens can help you find the right framing, then a sharper prime is often a better final choice if you have one. Use the camera’s lowest ISO and stop the lens down to its sharpest aperture, while avoiding very small apertures that may increase diffraction.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer