Can I mount a circular polarizer behind a 100mm slot-in filter holder?
Asked 7/17/2017
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m considering a 100mm slot-in filter system (such as a Cokin Z-Pro style holder) for use with my Nikon D7200 and Sigma 17-50mm f/2.8 (77mm thread). Instead of buying the large 105mm polarizer made for the holder, can I mount a smaller circular polarizer directly on the lens first, then attach the holder adapter and filter holder in front of it?
The setup would be: camera → lens → circular polarizer → holder adapter → filter holder → 100mm filters.
Will this work optically, and are there any practical drawbacks I should be aware of?
Originally by user65796. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user65796
9y ago
2 Answers
1
Yes you can do this. There is no problem, from an optical standpoint, doing this.
As mentioned in other answers, polarizers need to be able to rotate to the correct polarization angle in order to be effective.
I own the Lee Filter System, and have done exactly what you are trying to do. It is only a slight hassle to deal with trying to rotate the polarizer behind the filter holder.
If the square filter holder "snaps" on, rather than screws on, to the lens or the filter holder adapter, this is ideal. You can leave the filter holder off the lens, compose your scene, adjust the polarizer, then use a piece of tape (such as gaffer's tape — I always carry gaffer tape in my bag) to keep the polarizer from rotating while I fiddle with the filter holder.
I also own, and rarely use, a 95 mm in front of the filter holder. From experience, there is actually a very good reason not to use a large CPL in front of the filter holder, and prefer to use a CPL mounted directly onto the lens: there is no possibility of light leak behind a filter that is screwed onto a lens.
With a filter holder, you have to be careful to shield the tops, bottoms, and sides of the filters from stray light entering between the filters. A CPL mounted in front of the stack also suffers from this problem. Every flat glass (or resin) surface in front a lens is a potential reflection problem, and that problem is exacerbated if light can enter from the sides, between or behind filters.
Finally, there is currently another option on the market. NiSi makes a 100mm × 100mm filter holder that comes with a thin CPL that screws in inside the filter adapter ring, behind the filter stack. The base of the filter holder has a friction thumbwheel to allow you to rotate the CPL mounted inside. The filter is decent, and the holder is nicer (in my opinion) than Cokin's. Also, it comes in a rather nice leather protective box, reminiscent of older photographic lens and camera cases.
Originally by user11924. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11924
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — optically, this can work fine. A polarizer is effectively an optical flat, so placing it between the lens and the slot-in holder is generally not a problem.
The main issue is practical, not optical: a polarizer must be rotated to set the effect. If it sits behind the holder, adjusting it can be awkward. If rotating the polarizer also causes the holder or other filters to move, that can be inconvenient, especially with graduated filters that need precise alignment.
If your holder can be removed and reattached easily, a workable approach is to compose first, rotate the polarizer to the desired effect, then attach the holder carefully so the polarizer doesn’t shift.
Also, on a modern DSLR, make sure you use a circular polarizer rather than a linear polarizer. Linear polarizers can interfere with autofocus and metering.
So: yes, it will work, but ease of use may be the deciding factor.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can you stack a circular ND behind a square graduated ND filter holder?
Can you use a screw-on variable ND filter with a Cokin Z square filter holder?
Which Cokin filter system works with a Canon 6D and lenses from 17-40mm to 100-400mm?
Can you use a reverse-mount adapter with a zoom lens?
Adapter to mount a Mitutoyo 26mm/36tpi objective to a 77mm filter thread